|
|
||||||||
Faculty of Applied Health Sciences, Brock University, St. Catharines, Ontario, Canada L2S 3A1
Submitted 22 April 2003 ; accepted in final form 5 August 2003
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
aerobic fitness; secretory immunoglobulin A; upper respiratory tract infection
In addition to intense exercise, cortisol levels and body composition have been associated with immunosuppression. Hucklebridge et al. (15) have shown that increased psychological stress resulting in increased cortisol secretion caused a decreased rate of salivary IgA secretion. Other studies have shown that, as cortisol levels increase during stressful situations, SIgA also increases (6, 43). Nieman et al. (31, 33) did not find any relationship between URTI and body mass index in elite marathon runners. However, in a study on obese women, a significant relationship between obesity and elevated levels of leukocytes and lymphocytes was seen (34). Obesity was also related to suppressed levels of monocyte and mitogen-stimulated lymphocyte proliferation, as well as other immune markers, supporting the concept that obesity is associated with alterations in, and even suppression of, immunity (34).
It has long been suspected that the younger the individual, the less effective the immune defense. When examining the expression of IgA in children, Gleeson et al. (9) found significant fluctuation in salivary IgA levels. Salivary IgA was found to peak at the age of 5 yr, decrease slightly until the age of 7, and then remain relatively stable to age 9 (9). Other studies comparing children to adults found that children did not achieve adult levels of immunoregulation until they were almost 11 yr old (35). However, these studies did not control for other factors, such as diet, climate, season, or amount of exposure and/or contact to densely populated areas, all of which could have significantly affected the immune system. Very few studies have tried to link immunity to physical activity in youth. There are scant data comparing SIgA levels and the incidence of URTI in moderately active children to those of sedentary children. Tharp (41) found that resting SIgA levels increased over time in children who trained for, and played, basketball. Boas et al. (3) did not find any significant differences in leukocyte and lymphocyte levels, natural killer cells, and natural killer cell activity between trained and untrained children, 917 yr of age. A study of 8- to 10-yr-old children found no relationship between peak O2 consumption (
O2) and immune function, but body mass was found to be significantly correlated with SIgA concentration, serum leukocyte counts, monocytes, and granulocyte phagocytosis (32). Recently, adolescents who spent less time in sport activities have also reported significantly higher URTI frequency (17).
The goal of this study was to examine relationships between mucosal immunity, physical fitness levels, stress levels, and relative body fat in 10- to 11-yr-old children attending public schools in Southern Ontario, Canada. It was hypothesized that low levels of physical activity and elevated levels of resting salivary cortisol and body fat would result in decreased resting SIgA and higher frequency of URTI. A secondary objective of this work was to test the long-term reproducibility of both resting salivary cortisol and IgA for repeated measures taken 6 wk apart.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Physical activity and fitness assessments. Predicted peak aerobic power was estimated by using the 20-m shuttle run of Léger and Lambert (19). Subjects continued through the stages until they could no longer keep pace with the cadence of the tape, and the last completed stage was recorded. An estimate of each individual's peak
O2 was determined by multiplying the metabolic equivalent (MET) value associated with the final completed level of activity by 4.6 ml · kg1 · min1 for 1 MET, as suggested by Allor and Pivarnik (1). This test has been validated against a direct laboratory protocol (r = 0.91, SE of the estimate = 4.16), and the reproducibility has been reported (r = 0.975) for measurements taken on the same subject within a 1-wk period (19). In addition, this measurement has been shown to be a valid test in a school setting for children 617 yr of age (20).
The Habitual Activity Estimation Scale (HAES) was used to estimate the time spent in all forms of habitual activity, i.e., the number of hours of habitual physical activity per day (13). The questionnaire divides a day into four periods, and activities are ranked according to intensity. Total duration of daily activity was then used to calculate the total weekly habitual activity (h/wk). Total activity time has been proposed as a more appropriate measurement for children than the combined energy cost of physical activities (13). The validity of the HAES has been evaluated by Hay (13), and the test-retest reliability was found to be >0.80 (13, 14).
The Participation Questionnaire was used to estimate both the amount of physical activity and the nature of the participation by using three categories: free-time activity, organized activity time, and total time spent in activities (12). Participation scores are referred to as activity units. Each unit refers to participation in one activity on a regular or seasonal basis. An activity unit in the organized sport section refers to participation on a single sport team (either school or community), playing on an intramural team, or participating in a series of lessons. An activity unit in the free-choice section refers to any active leisure pursuit as a preferred choice after school, on weekends, or with family and friends (12). The Participation Questionnaire has been validated against the Teachers' Evaluation of Physical Activity (r = 0.62), and test-retest reliability was reported to be 0.81 for grades 48 and 0.89 for grades 912 (12).
Total distance traveled per day was measured by using a Digi-Walker pedometer (New Lifestyles). The device recorded the child's physical activity in steps by using a step counter. Each individual's step was measured to the nearest centimeter. The steps counted by the pedometer were then multiplied by the individual's stride length to determine total distance traveled in meters. All subjects were required to use the Digi-Walker for 2 consecutive days. Each monitor was calibrated to accurately record the movements of the subject. A 2-day activity log accompanied the pedometer. The subjects recorded daily physical activities other than general locomotion. The log ensured that data recorded by the pedometer were valid, accurate, and reliably recorded. The Digi-Walker pedometer was chosen because of stability and reliability, in addition to cost effectiveness and ease of operation. Welk and Wood (42) examined the Digi-Walker to determine its effectiveness as a tool for assessing physical activity patterns. The pedometers tended to underpredict high-intensity activities, simply because fewer steps were needed to complete the activity. As a result, distinguishing between differing levels of physical activity may not be possible. However, the authors do support use of the pedometer as an indicator of daily activity (42).
Body fat measurements. Bioelectrical impedance analysis was used to estimate the percent body fat by using the input variables of physical activity level, body frame size, height, mass, and gender, as previously described (21). The skin was cleaned with 70% alcohol, and four surface electrodes were applied: two on the right hand at the second metacarpal and the wrist between the styloid processes of the radius and ulna, and two on the right foot at the second metatarsal and the ankle between the medial and lateral malleoli. With the subject supine, an electrical current of 50 kHz and 0.8 mA was applied through the electrodes to determine whole body resistance (Quantum II, RJL Systems). Short- and long-term reproducibility of this technique has been reported as r = 0.999 for measurements made on the same subject within 1 wk, and 0.977 for repeat measurements up to 1 mo apart, resulting in a coefficient of variance of 2.5% (18). All participants were provided written information to standardize the procedure, and bioelectrical impedance analysis measurements were made before the shuttle run to avoid problems associated with dehydration and changes in skin temperature, electrolyte concentration, and glycogen stores (18). The validity and reliability of this method has been demonstrated successfully in children and adolescents (36, 40).
Saliva testing. After body composition assessment, subjects submitted to collection of two saliva samples. For each of these samples, 1 ml of unstimulated, whole mixed saliva was collected by using cylinder-shaped swabs (SARSTEDT, Quebec, Canada) placed in the mouth. Subjects were instructed to moisten and chew lightly on the swab for 1 min. After a 2-min interval, a second sample was collected. Because there is evidence that acute maximal exercise results in a delayed onset of cortisol secretion, care was taken to ensure that the saliva samples were collected with sufficient time after the aerobic power test to avoid this effect. After collection of the first sample, temperature of the subject was taken by using an auditory thermometer (Firsttemp Genius, model 3000A, Tympanic Thermometer, Mansfield, MA) to ensure that cortisol contained in the second saliva sample was not affected by acute stress. After sampling, the swabs were placed directly into plastic tubes and then stored by using standard procedures at 20°C (8) until the samples were centrifuged to extract the saliva from the swab and assayed. The subjects were instructed not to consume any food or drink for at least 1 h before saliva collection, and the mouth was not rinsed with water before sampling, to avoid altering resting SIgA levels.
SIgA in saliva was measured by radial immunodiffusion by using the BINARID kit (Binding Site Limited) (6, 25). Radial immunodiffusion developed by Mancini et al. (25) involves a quantitative gel diffusion technique with antibody incorporated into the agar. More specifically, an agar plate is prepared by incorporating antibody throughout the agar. The test sample is put into a small antigen well and, on diffusion into the agar, forms a ring of antibody-antigen precipitate around the well. The diameter of the precipitate ring reflects the concentration of the antigen. As the protein concentration in saliva is dependent on a number of factors, including vascular permeability and mouth dryness, it is recommended that the concentration of SIgA be related to the level of salivary albumin (Alb) present in the sample (6, 25). Results were, therefore, expressed as SIgA-to-Alb ratio (SIgA/Alb). Because the literature suggests that salivary concentration is influenced by the time of the day and the saliva collection method (2), saliva samples were collected at the same time during the day, in the morning, by using the same collection method. The reliability for SIgA/Alb was r = 0.82.
Cortisol levels were assessed by using a DPC coat-a-count cortisol kit. Total plasma concentrations of cortisol were measured in duplicate by commercial solid-phase 125I radioimmunoassay kits. 125I-labeled cortisol competes for antibody sites for cortisol within the sample. The antibody is bound to the wall of the polypropylene tube, so when the supernatant is decanted, the antibody-bound fraction of the radiolabeled cortisol is still present. The amount of cortisol present in the sample is measured by a gamma counter. Reference ranges are from 3.5 to 27.0 nmol/l at 8 AM and <6.0 nmol/l at 10 PM for both genders and all ages, including children.
Frequency of URTI. A 1-mo health log (34) was used to record the incidence and duration (number of days) of URTIs. Subjects recorded cold and flu symptoms each day of the month by using a set of codes provided with the log. The severity of the symptoms was rated by each subject as mild, moderate, or severe. Parental supervision was required to ensure accurate recording of the symptoms. This method was chosen to eliminate participant bias when recording from memory. All logs were also completed during the Northern hemisphere's spring-summer (April to June), which is a moderate- to high-infection season for Canada. The total number of days with URTI symptoms was calculated for each subject, with days being counted only if 2 or more consecutive days of cold or flu symptoms were reported (34).
A randomly selected subgroup (n = 15) was assessed a second time, 6 wk after initial testing. Follow-up testing was conducted to examine the reproducibility of salivary measures. During this follow-up visit, all of the tests were repeated.
Statistical analysis. One-way ANOVA was used to compare boys and girls on physical activity, percent body fat, aerobic power, SIgA, and salivary cortisol. Pearson correlation analysis was used to detect relationships among all the variables, and intraclass correlation analysis was used to test the reproducibility of resting salivary cortisol and IgA measures (before and 6 wk after). All data analyses were conducted by using SPSS 11 for Windows. A minimum value of P
0.05 was accepted to indicate a statistically significant result. All data were checked for normality and equality of distribution before any analysis was performed.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
O2 and in distance traveled per day (Table 2). No significant difference was evident between genders in reported levels of physical activity and relative body fat. There was no significant difference between genders in either SIgA or SIgA/Alb (Table 2).
|
Based on the HAES questionnaire, children who were active <3 h/day were considered hypoactive, whereas those who recorded activity levels >3 h/day were considered active. Twenty-two percent of boys reported <3 h/day of habitual physical activity, whereas 31.8% of girls did not achieve this level. As shown in Table 3, the hypoactive children had significantly lower predicted peak
O2 and SIgA/Alb, as well as significantly higher relative body fat and frequency of URTI. Moreover, body fat values revealed that 40% of the children (50% of boys and 42% of girls) had relative body fat >25%. Children with relative body fat higher than 25% reported significantly more days with cold and flu symptoms and total sick days than the rest of the cohort (Fig. 1).
|
|
As shown in Table 4, organized activity and free-time activity were significantly related to peak
O2. The total activity score was significantly correlated with peak
O2, distance traveled per day, and resting salivary cortisol levels. Distance traveled per day was also significantly correlated with peak
O2, as well as with time spent in organized sport activities. Salivary cortisol was significantly correlated with body fat and time spent in organized sport. SIgA and SIgA/Alb demonstrated a significant relationship only with incidence of URTI (Table 4). The incidence of URTI was also correlated with total activity score, weekly habitual activity, and resting salivary cortisol (Table 4).
|
The intraclass correlation coefficient for initial and post-6-wk measures of salivary cortisol was r = 0.66. The intraclass correlation coefficients for SIgA and SIgA/Alb were r = 0.23 and r = 0.20, respectively. When the means were compared, initial and post-6-wk measurements of SIgA and SIgA/Alb were not significantly different.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
When examining the total cohort, there was no significant relationship between SIgA and body fat. This is in contrast to the results of Nieman et al. (32), who found that there was a correlation between body fat levels and SIgA in children. In addition, when categorized by relative body fat values, children in the present study with body fat >25% did report a higher frequency of flu and cold symptoms than their counterparts. Salivary IgA levels and SIgA/Alb were not significantly related to cortisol levels either. Cortisol has been shown to be an indicator of stress (4). Our results would seem to suggest that stress may not have any more of an effect on secretory immunity in children than physical activity does. Nevertheless, a correlation between higher salivary cortisol and lower incidence of URTI was found (Table 4). Resting levels of salivary cortisol as well as incidence of URTI and SIgA were not correlated with aerobic fitness (Table 4). Other studies have also demonstrated that immune function indicators and cortisol levels are independent of aerobic fitness level (27).
No gender differences were found in levels of SIgA and SIgA/Alb among the children in the present study. Schouten et al. (38) observed gender differences in SIgA levels in adults. Their subjects, however, were in job situations in which they were not necessarily exposed to increased infection levels as children are, and not all of the subjects were exposed to the same work environment.
Salivary analysis is a practical way to measure biochemical markers in children. One of the objectives of the present study was to determine whether salivary cortisol and SIgA concentrations were reliable tools for assessing resting stress and immunity levels in younger individuals. Several studies report that adult levels of SIgA (27) and salivary IgA are reached between 1 and 7 yr of age (8, 39), but there are very few published reports on short- or long-term reproducibility of SIgA, especially in children. In the present study, SIgA, SIgA/Alb, and salivary cortisol values were reexamined after 6 wk. The interclass correlation coefficient was high (r = 0.66) for cortisol and low for both SIgA (r = 0.23) and SIgA/Alb (r = 0.20). This indicates that the initial and post-6-wk values for SIgA and SIgA/Alb were not significantly related. In contrast, it is interesting to note that initial and post-6-wk values of both of these variables were not significantly different, as shown by ANOVA. Gleeson et al. (8) also found variability in SIgA levels in the children's saliva samples from the ages of 1 to 5, but concluded that, because there seemed to be a plateau from 5 to 7 yr of age, SIgA would remain relatively stable from that point on. Because SIgA was not significantly related to any of the other variables, it is reasonable to believe that SIgA, although very practical as a tool for assessing state of immunity in children, may not be a reliable measure when used alone. However, given the small sample size in this study, it would be premature to conclude that it does not provide useful information when screening secretory immunity in children. Salivary IgA levels change in a yearly circadian rhythm in adults (29). Circadian rhythm in this case refers to a predictable change in SIgA and serum IgA that is determined by the seasons. Winter or colder temperatures cause an increase in concentration of SIgA and serum IgA, whereas warmer temperatures or summer are linked to a decrease in SIgA and serum IgA. The rhythm in children may be more complex. It is possible that the time of day or year, or the type of environmental exposure (i.e., in school or not) could all affect the values.
In summary, this study showed that SIgA is not significantly correlated with salivary cortisol levels, physical activity, body fat, and cardiorespiratory fitness in 10- to 11-yr-old children. Salivary IgA levels seem to vary in this age group. This variability needs to be investigated further so that a definitive statement can be made about the reproducibility of secretory immunity measures. This study supports the importance of physical activity for children's resistance to infection. Children who spent more time in sport activities and had higher aerobic fitness reported fewer sick days, whereas children with relative body fat exceeding 25% reported significantly more sick days than the rest of the cohort.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
O2 max. Eur J Appl Physiol 49: 112, 1982.
O2 on immune function in children. Int J Obes 26: 822829, 2002.[Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
B. W. Timmons Exercise and Immune Function in Children American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine, January 1, 2007; 1(1): 59 - 66. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Visit Other APS Journals Online |