|
|
||||||||
1 Department of Anesthesiology, Perioperative and Pain Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, and 2 Physiology Program, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts 02115
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The pressure-volume (P-V) characteristics of the lung microcirculation are important determinants of the pattern of pulmonary perfusion and of red and white cell transit times. Using diffuse light scattering, we measured capillary P-V loops in seven excised perfused dog lobes at four lung volumes, from functional residual capacity (FRC) to total lung capacity (TLC), over a wide range of vascular transmural pressures (Ptm). At Ptm 5 cmH2O, specific compliance of the microvasculature was 8.6%/cmH2O near FRC, decreasing to 2.7%/cmH2O as lung volume increased to TLC. At low lung volumes, the vasculature showed signs of strain stiffening (specific compliance fell as Ptm rose), but stiffening decreased as lung volume increased and was essentially absent at TLC. The P-V loops were smooth without sharp transitions, consistent with vascular distension as the primary mode of changes in vascular volume with changes in Ptm. Hysteresis was small (0.013) at all lung volumes, suggesting that, although surface tension may set basal capillary shape, it does not strongly affect capillary compliance.
capillary; diffuse light scattering; transit time; dog; hysteresis; mechanics
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
THE PRESSURE-VOLUME (P-V) characteristics of the lung microcirculation are important determinants of the pattern of pulmonary perfusion both regionally as well as on the smaller acinar scale. In addition, the pressures, volumes, and flows within the capillaries interact to influence gas exchange through red cell transit times. Importantly, the fact that the capillaries are mechanically linked to the alveolar septa and their stress-bearing support structures implies that capillary mechanics are likely to be influenced by lung volume (VL) and lung recoil pressure, which are continuously changing during breathing.
The mechanical properties of capillaries affect the transit times of erythrocytes (RBC) and leukocytes (PMN) but in different ways. To the extent that RBCs simply follow the local perfusion, the local ratio of capillary volume to blood flow determines the transit times. By contrast, because the diameter of PMNs is larger than the diameter of the capillaries (7, 18, 22, 23, 33), their transit times and, hence, sequestration are in part determined by the interaction of PMN deformability and capillary diameters. Whether changes in capillary volume occur through recruitment and derecruitment of segments or through vessel distension remains an open question.
Previous studies of the P-V characteristics of the pulmonary
vasculature have involved microscopic sectioning after either freezing
(13) or perfusion with elastomers (11), or
have been limited to vessels larger than capillaries (e.g., Refs. 1 and 17 and others as summarized by Al-Tinawi et al. in Ref. 1), or to
subpleural capillaries (14). Apart from these studies, little is known from direct measurements about the compliance of the
capillaries (vessels <20-µm diameter) over a wide range of
vascular transmural pressures (Ptm) and VL. In a previous
report (30), we measured the fractional changes in
pulmonary vascular blood volume (
Vc/Vc) during the cardiac cycle in
rabbit lung parenchyma, where more than two-thirds of the blood has
been shown to be in pulmonary capillaries (8, 18). In this
study, we measured
Vc/Vc in excised perfused dog lungs during slow
oscillations of pulmonary vascular pressure and after step changes in
vascular volume over a wide range of Ptms and over a range of
VL. We determined how vascular compliance changes with
VL and whether the vasculature showed evidence of strain
stiffening (a decrease of compliance with increasing Ptm). Finally, we
quantified the hysteresis in P-V loops and examined their shapes for
evidence of capillary recruitment.
| |
METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Animal preparation. We studied seven female mongrel dogs (18.5-22 kg). Each animal was anesthetized with pentobarbital sodium, initial dose ~15 mg/kg iv, with additional doses as needed to maintain adequate anesthesia (total ~25 mg/kg). The animal was placed supine, a tracheotomy was performed below the larynx, and the trachea was cannulated with a cuffed endotracheal tube. Blood gases and pH were monitored (Ciba Corning model 248). In most cases, the dog breathed air spontaneously, but, if necessary to restore arterial partial pressure of CO2 to 38-40 Torr, the dog was ventilated (respiratory rate 4-6 breaths/min, tidal volume 200-400 ml, 100% O2). Heparin (40,000 units iv) was given, and at least 2 min later the dog was exsanguinated via a femoral artery catheter. The blood was collected, and sodium bicarbonate was added as needed to keep the pH near 7.4. The measured hemoglobin concentration ranged from 11.3 to 14.6 grams per 100 ml. After ~1,000 ml of blood had been collected, the animal was killed with an overdose of pentobarbital sodium iv. As rapidly as practical, a median sternotomy was performed, and the heart and lungs were excised en bloc. Except for momentary episodes during lung excision, lung inflation was maintained by use of positive pressure at the airway opening (Pao). The lung was kept moist by spraying it with 0.9% saline.
The left or right lower lobe was isolated, and its pulmonary artery (PA) and vein (PV) were isolated and cannulated with large-bore catheters (18- to 24-Fr). The lobar bronchus was cannulated with a 4-mm tube. To limit intravascular air as much as possible, the PV catheter was initially back-flushed with saline, and then both the PA and PV cannulas were connected to a perfusion circuit that was filled with autologous blood. The mean time from death until perfusion was reestablished was 45 min (range 41-50 min). The lobe was suspended by the cannulas. To keep the pleural surface moist and to prevent gas exchange through the pleural surface, a flaccid plastic bag, ventilated with the same gas used for ventilating the lobe, was placed around the lobe. Between measurements, the lobe was ventilated with 95% O2 and 5% CO2 [Siemens 900, pressure-controlled mode, respiratory rate 10 breaths/min, transpulmonary pressure (PL) at end expiration ~4 cmH2O, PL at end inspiration ~15 cmH2O]. Figure 1 shows a schematic of the perfusion circuit. An adjustable roller pump (Stockert Shiley model 10) pumped blood from a reservoir through a heat exchanger, which kept the blood at 37-38°C, into the PA; blood drained passively from the PV into the reservoir. The height of the reservoir could be adjusted to control the PV pressure (Ppv), or the PA pressure (Ppa) if the bypass around the pump was open. Vascular pressures were measured (Sorenson Abbott Transpac 2) at the PA and PV cannulas, with the transducer heights matched to the height on the lobe where the optical probe was placed (midlobe and far from any margin). Vascular pressures were measured relative to barometric pressure, which, in this case, was the same as pleural pressure. Between measurements, the height of the reservoir was set at midlobe level, and the pump was set to a flow that resulted in a Ppa of ~20 cmH2O (usually ~100-200 ml/min).
|
Optical methods. Point illumination of the pleural surface of the lung results in a distinctive pattern of backscattered light from which the fractional change in blood volume can be derived (30). Optical fibers delivered laser light of two wavelengths (693 and 808 nm; output powers ~30 mW) to a point on the lobe surface and carried backscattered light from the lobe surface back to sensing photodiodes (Fig. 1). The two source fibers (each 0.008 mm2) were held together at the animal end, such that the center-to-center distance was ~0.135 mm. Each of the three receiving fibers had an area of 0.290 mm2. The animal end of the source and the receiving fibers were held securely in a plastic block (area 1.9 × 5 cm, height 2.9 cm), such that the fibers were in a fixed position relative to each other. The fibers and block were supported by a flexible gooseneck stand and placed gently against the lung, with the fibers approximately perpendicular to the lung surface. The lasers were cycled alternately on and off, with a duty cycle of 0.25 and a period of 8 ms. The signal from each photodiode was demultiplexed and provided wavelength-specific light intensity at each known radial distance from the source fibers.
Before each experiment, the offsets and gains of each receiving channel were determined. The electronic offsets (i.e., the dark signal level) were measured with the receiving fibers shielded from light. These offsets were subtracted from all measured intensities. The gains of channels 1 and 2 relative to channel 3 (picked as the reference channel) for each wavelength were measured as follows. The source and receiving fibers were placed in an array of holes in an opaque box filled with an open-cell foam that diffusely scattered the incoming light. The order of the receiving fibers was sequentially permuted. The ratios of the intensities in these permutations of distance from the source then gave the relative gains for each receiving channel (consisting of a fiber, photodiode, and signal processor).Experimental protocol.
Each experiment involved two different, quasi-static interventions at
four different airway pressures: 1) slow oscillations of
vascular pressure or 2) step changes in vascular volume. The perfusion pump was off while data were collected. Oscillations in
vascular pressure were generated, 54 runs in seven dogs, by slowly
raising and lowering the blood reservoir connected to either the PA or
PV, while the cannula to the other vessel was clamped. Each pressure
cycle took 10-60 s, and the rate was adjusted in an attempt to
keep Ppa and Ppv as close to each other as practical. During each data
collection period, the vascular pressure was cycled 3-5 times.
Microcirculatory intravascular pressure (Pvas) was defined as the
pressure in the vessel that was clamped during the maneuver, either Ppa
or Ppv, because there was minimal flow (and therefore minimal
flow-resistive pressure loss) between the capillaries and the clamped
vessel. Ptm was defined as Pvas
Pao. Ppa and Ppv were varied
such that Ptm during each cycle covered the range ~
1.4 to +16
cmH2O in the first three dogs and ~
6.5 to +40
cmH2O in the last four
dogs.1
~40 cmH2O. During
injections, the reservoir was excluded from the circuit. Because the
compliance of the entire perfusion circuit, excluding the reservoir,
was negligible, essentially all of the injected blood entered the vasculature.
Measurements were made at PL of 4, 10, 20, and 30 cmH2O, chosen to cover the range from functional residual
capacity (FRC) to total lung capacity (TLC). Before each data
collection period, the lobe was exposed to a standard volume history;
PL was cycled from 2 to 30 cmH2O three times
and then deflated from 30 cmH2O to the target
PL.
Data acquisition. Raw signals from each pressure transducer (Ppa, Ppv, Pao) and the wavelength-specific light intensities at the three known distances from the optical origin were sampled at 100 Hz per channel and stored on computer using a 12-bit analog-to-digital board and data acquisition software (both Dataq Instruments, Akron, OH). All raw data were averaged over 1-s intervals. These averages were used in all subsequent analyses.
Data analysis and statistics.
The rate of change of light intensity with distance from the source is
a direct measure of the wavelength-specific diffuse absorption
coefficients, from which the fractional change in blood volume can be
derived (see APPENDIX A). We reduced all
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm
data at each VL to three outcome variables: 1) the specific compliance at Ptm = 5 cmH2O,
2) the rate of change of specific compliance with vascular
pressure, and 3) the hysteresis of the
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm
loops. This was accomplished as follows.
Vc/Vc vs. time and Ptm vs. time curves, straight lines that both preserved the means and connected the
beginning and end points. During step changes in vascular volume, data
were also recorded continuously, but data collected during the sharp
transients (~2 s) seen during each injection were discarded.
Fractional changes in blood volume are measured relative to a reference
volume, that is, the capillary volume at a reference Ptm.
Vc/Vc was
regressed quadratically against Ptm, constrained such that
Vc/Vc was
zero at the reference Ptm of 5 cmH2O. We defined the
derivative and second derivative of each regression, at Ptm = 5 cmH2O, as the microvascular specific compliance (Cc) and
rate of change of specific compliance (dCc/dPtm), respectively. Note that, at each VL, changes in blood volume density are
normalized to the blood volume density at Ptm = 5 cmH2O. A negative value of dCc/dPtm denotes strain
stiffening, i.e., a decrease in compliance as vascular Ptm increases.
Finally, the hysteresis was computed as the ratio of the average area
bounded by the loops to the average size of the
Vc/Vc vs. Pvas
circumscribing rectangle (16). The average loop area was
computed by dividing the total area of all loops by the number of
loops. The average circumscribing rectangle area was computed as the
product of the average peak-to-peak
Vc/Vc and the average
peak-to-peak Ptm.
We found a curvilinear relationship of both Cc and dCc/dPtm vs.
PL but a linear relationship of both Cc and dCc/dPtm vs.
VL. VL was estimated to be 40 (FRC), 75, 90, and 100% TLC at PL of 4, 10, 20, and 30 cmH2O,
respectively (12, 21). This allowed us to simplify
statistical modeling by grouping data from all dogs by the estimated
VL at which they were collected. Values are reported as
means ± SE of all points from all dogs at each VL. We
used a general linear model and performed an ANOVA to determine which
experimental parameters and control variables resulted in changes in an
outcome variable (Cc, dCc/dPtm, or hysteresis). The experimental
parameters and control variables were: VL, perfusate pH and
PCO2, maximum and minimum Ptm, and length of
time from when the animal was killed until data collection. Indicator
variables were used for individual animals, intervention (slow
oscillations of vascular pressure or step change in vascular volume),
and site of pressure oscillation (PA or PV). A parameter was defined as significant if its regression coefficient was significantly different from zero, P < 0.05.
The slopes and intercepts of the regression lines for both Cc and
dCc/dPtm vs. VL for the two interventions (slow
oscillations in Pvas and between step changes in vascular volume) were
not significantly different from each other, and so the data obtained using both methods were pooled for further analysis.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Figure 2 shows examples of
Vc/Vc
vs. Ptm data from four separate data collection periods at constant
PL of 10 and 30 cmH2O. The loops are composed
of data collected during slow oscillations of vascular pressure. The
points are data collected during the pauses between four step changes
in vascular volume.
|
Cc decreased significantly as VL increased. Figure
3 shows the pooled mean Cc at each
VL for all animals and the linear regression. In one
animal, Cc was significantly lower than for the other six. Cc also
varied significantly with the length of time from death until data
collection. Despite its statistical significance, the magnitude of the
time effect was not physiologically important (<0.22%/cmH2O). The other experimental parameters and
control variables had no statistically significant effects on Cc.
|
At PL = 4 cmH2O, the scatter of the data was
large (Fig. 3), and P-V loops were more variable. There are both
physiological and technical factors that may have contributed to this
finding. First, at low VL, the lung is very compliant, and
small variations in PL result in large variations in
VL and acinar dimensions, which could have resulted in
large variations in the actual Cc. VL errors would also
have resulted in variation in the diffuse absorption coefficient used
in calculations of
Vc/Vc. Second, at low VL, the lung
was less physically stable and tended to move relative to the optical
sensors as blood volume changed during oscillations or step maneuvers.
Third, the slight amount of pressure exerted by the optical probe may
have caused more variable deformation of the lung at low
VL.
At low VL, Cc decreased significantly as Ptm increased,
i.e., the vessels exhibited strain stiffening. This effect decreased significantly as VL increased and was essentially absent at
TLC. Figure 4 illustrates, at each
VL, how Cc would change as a function of Ptm. The other
experimental parameters and control variables had no statistically
significant effects on dCc/dPtm.
|
The mean hysteresis of
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm loops during slow oscillations
of Ptm was 0.013 ± 0.0054. Hysteresis did not vary significantly with VL or other experimental parameters and control
variables, except indicator variables for individual animals and
maximum Ptm during the data collection run.
The shapes of
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm loops during slow oscillations of Ptm
were smooth. We observed no sharp transitions that would have suggested
recruitment over a narrow range of opening pressures (see
DISCUSSION).
If all of the 10 ml injected during each bolus injection had distended
the capillaries, then
Vc/Vc could be used to estimate upper limits
of the baseline capillary blood volume. Calculated values of capillary
blood volume (Vc) based on these estimates were unrealistically
high, suggesting that, as expected, a substantial fraction of
the bolus injection distended parts of the vasculature outside our
sampled volume (p. 99, Fig. 4 in Ref. 10, and Ref. 29).
Between bolus injections, the Ppa-Ppv differences were small (root mean
square ~1 cmH2O). However, even though Ppa
Ppv oscillated around 0 cmH2O during slow-pressure
oscillations, the Ppa and Ppv did not track each other as well as
expected (root mean square ~4 cmH2O). The pressure
difference often persisted even when the pressure was held constant
(the height of the reservoir bag was unchanged) for several seconds.
The Ppa-Ppv differences were most likely due to persistent blood flow
either into or out of the reservoir or via redistribution within the vasculature.
Just after each set of data was obtained, blood draining from the lobe was collected and analyzed for pH and PCO2. The mean pH was 7.45 (range 7.40-7.57). The mean PCO2 was 33 (range 21-40) Torr. The interval from an animal's death until an individual data set was collected ranged from 70 to 280 min.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We measured the P-V characteristics of the pulmonary
microvasculature over a wide range of Ptm and VL. The major
findings were: 1) the compliance of the microvasculature was
~8%/cmH2O at FRC, decreasing with increasing
VL to ~2.7%/cmH2O at TLC, 2) vessels exhibited strain stiffening at low VL but much less
at higher VL, 3) loops of
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm had
little hysteresis, and 4) shapes of the P-V loops support
vascular distension rather than recruitment as the primary mode of
volume change. In the following paragraphs, we quantitatively compare
our measures of Cc with those of others, then discuss the key
physiological implications of these findings.
Capillary compliance.
Figure 5 shows our estimates of Cc and
estimates based on the data of others. There are no other data
available on Cc near FRC. At PL 10 cmH2O, our
value is close to those of previous studies. However, at higher
PL there is a striking difference. Unlike Glazier et al.
(13), we found a lower, not a higher, compliance at
increased PL. This result is consistent with our earlier
work in rabbits (30), which showed that Vc fluctuated
during the cardiac cycle at low, but not at high, VL, which
suggested that compliance falls as VL rises. We believe our
data are most appropriately compared with Glazier's data for change in
RBCs per length of capillary segment, not to their data for change in
capillary width (all are shown in Fig. 5). Because, at fixed
VL, capillary segment lengths are fixed and all volume
changes occur through proportional changes in area (28),
we believe the change in number of RBCs per length of capillary segment
is analogous to our optical measure of blood (hemoglobin) volume per
unit volume.
|
Mechanism of changes in compliance with VL.
We found that Cc decreased as VL increased, but this need
not have been the case; in fact, Glazier et al. (13) found
the opposite relationship between Cc and VL (Fig. 5). On
the one hand, as VL increases, so do vessel lengths and
tissue forces (Pt) (e.g., p. 327 in Ref. 32, and Ref. 14),
as well as surface tension (
). All of these contribute to decreased
Cc. On the other hand, as VL increases, the alveolar
capillaries become flatter in cross section (p. 327 in Ref. 32). Such a
change in geometry can substantially increase compliance by providing a
pathway for volume displacement with little or no change in
circumference and therefore tissue strain. In addition, if vessels had
a smaller baseline volume at high VL, as suggested by the
data of Glazier et al. (13), then the same absolute change
in volume would result in a greater specific compliance. We conclude
from the increased stiffness we found at higher VL that
either increased Pt or
, rather than change in vessel
shape or baseline volume, dominates the change in Cc as VL
changes. The complex effects of
are discussed below.
Changes in compliance with Ptm. At low VL, the compliance of the pulmonary microcirculation decreased as Ptm increased; that is, vessels exhibited the strain stiffening typical of most tissue. At high VL, the capillaries were stiffer at all Ptm, but, surprisingly, strain stiffening decreased, and it was virtually absent above 90% TLC (Fig. 4). This suggests that, at high VL, changes in tissue geometry may result in more linear capillary P-V characteristics. Alternatively, supporting tissues with more linear stress-strain behavior, which were unimportant at lower VL, may come to dominate the capillary P-V characteristics.
Hysteresis.
We saw little hysteresis in loops of
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm. Our value
(0.013) is about one-fourth the steady-state value that Beck and
Hildebrandt (4) found for the entire pulmonary
circulation. In addition, they summarize other reports, all of which
find either no or low values of lung vascular P-V hysteresis. In
contrast, hysteresis of lung P-V loops, which are dominated by
, are
more than 10 times greater (2, 6). The low value that we
found for microvascular hysteresis implies that, even though pulmonary capillaries are exposed to an air-tissue interface,
has little influence on Cc (see below) and that vascular mechanics have little dependence on their volume history. This second finding is further supported by our experimental observation that Cc and dCc/dPtm values
were not significantly different when measured during slow pressure
oscillations (10-60 s) or after step changes in volume. The low
value of hysteresis also indicates that the pulmonary capillaries
behave in an almost purely elastic fashion in the sense that there is
little dissipative energy loss.
What does the low value of hysteresis imply about lung
architecture?
Imagine a pulmonary capillary, exposed to a surfactant-lined gas-liquid
interface. The changes in Ptm of such a vessel are the sum of the
changes in surface forces (P
) and Pt. Vc
doubled in our experiments, which would result in fractional changes of vessel surface area ~0.4 if the vessels were circular tubes. The
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm loops for these volume excursions had hysteresis values of 0.013. Yet, in vitro loops of
vs. surfactant area, associated with fractional changes in area of 0.4, result in hysteresis values >0.3 (20). This 20-fold difference in hysteresis
values suggests that either P
< Pt or the
vessels are noncircular and their surface area changed much less than
the anticipated 40%. P
in the lung is known to be
greater than, not substantially less than, Pt (p. 96 in
Ref. 19). Our data are inconsistent with any model of the pulmonary
capillary bed that, at fixed VL, involves substantial
change in area of an air liquid interface with changes in Ptm.
of 10 dyn/cm, then vessel P
=
/radius (LaPlace's law) would
be 34 cmH2O. This would make the capillary intravascular
pressure (P
+ Pt) > 30 cmH2O, which is much higher than known values.
In summary, the very low value of hysteresis suggests that
does
not, in a direct way, strongly affect Cc. Nonetheless, it may play an
important role in setting basal capillary shape, by keeping capillary
walls flat. The effects of changes in
on capillary mechanics need
further investigation.
Recruitment vs. distension.
The
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm curves were smooth and showed little hysteresis.
These features are consistent either with distension or with
recruitment of vessels with widely distributed, but equal, opening and
closing pressures. In other words, our data are not consistent with
recruitment whether there is a narrow range of opening pressures or
whether there are significant differences between opening and closing
pressures (independent of how distributed the pressures may be). In
particular, recruitment over a narrow range of opening pressures would
have resulted in loops with nearly vertical slopes at the opening
pressure, such as those found by Fung and Sobin (e.g., Ref. 11, Fig.
6.5:1, p. 307, at PL = 10-15 cmH2O) and by
Godbey et al. (Fig. 1A in Ref. 14 at PL = 2.7 cmH2O). Godbey et al. (14) suggest abrupt
opening at low VL but more distributed opening pressures at
higher VL. However, even at low VL and at Ptm
near zero, our loops of
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm were smooth and showed no
segments with nearly vertical slopes. Moreover, independent of the
distribution of opening pressures, significant differences between
opening and closing pressures would be reflected in significant
hysteresis in the overall P-V loops; we did not observe this at any
VL.
Vc/Vc is continuous. Our data demonstrate that blood persists in the
capillaries even at low Ptm, but this does not mean blood flow must be
present. A segment of the vessel downstream of the capillaries could be
closed at negative Ptm, trapping blood in capillaries. Albeit under
very different circumstances, an unperfused but ventilated lung remains
distinctly pink, as opposed to a lung perfused with a clear solution,
which has a starkly white appearance; this also suggests persistence of
blood in the pulmonary microvasculature.
What do these data imply about the distribution of pulmonary vascular resistance and compliance? During slow oscillation of vascular pressure, Cc, dCc/dPtm, and hysteresis values were all independent of the side of the pulmonary circulation to which we applied pressure. The symmetry of hysteresis values implies that there was no significant vascular compliance outside the sampled volume, or that any compliance outside the volume of view had a short time constant compared with the time course of the pressure oscillations. This is most consistent with a simple model of the pulmonary vasculature: upstream and downstream resistances, with an intervening capillary capacitance. By contrast, the falling Vc that we sometimes saw between step changes in vascular volume implies a redistribution of blood to regions with significant compliance outside the sampled volume. We attribute these differences to the different time courses of the pressure oscillations (10-60 s per cycle) vs. the step changes in volume (~2 s per injection).
Pressure swings in the pulmonary capillaries with changes in
and during the cardiac cycle.
Our results for microvascular compliance, which relate changes in Vc to
changes in Ptm, allow a semiquantitative estimate of the fractional
change in microvascular pressure, in zone III, with changes in cardiac
output (
). As has been pointed out (3, 24),
there are two effects. The first is direct: there is a simple increase
in Pvas due to the increased flow-resistive pressure loss. But the
increase in Pvas results in a decrease in resistance secondary to an
increase in vessel diameter, and this second, indirect, effect
attenuates the increase in Pvas. An expression describing these effects
(Eq. B4) is derived in APPENDIX B. Suppose we
started at FRC with Pvas = 5 cmH2O, left atrial
pressure (Pla) = 0 cmH2O, and Cc = 8%/cmH2O. Equation B4 predicts that if
doubled or quadrupled, then capillary pressure would increase 2 or 5 cmH2O, respectively, similar to values in the literature (e.g., Table 3 in Ref. 25 and p. 593 in Ref. 26). The point here is
that because the indirect effect of Cc on increases in Pvas with
is of the same order of magnitude as the direct effect, increases in
would result in only about half of the increase in
capillary pressures that would occur if Cc were zero. A more rigorous
examination of this issue can be found in Linehan et al.
(24).
Vc/Vc during the cardiac cycle at FRC is ~13%, as we previously found in rabbits
(30), the pressure swings in the capillaries would be
~1.6 cmH2O.
Changes in RBC transit time.
This same line of argument can be used to estimate the change in
transit times of RBCs with increasing
(the transit times of
PMNs are discussed below). If transit time falls to too low a value,
blood may pass through the lung without equilibrating with alveolar
gas. Here again there are two effects. The direct effect of increased
is simply to reduce transit time by moving blood more quickly
through the vascular bed, because transit time = Vc/
. The
indirect effect blunts the reduction in transit time by increasing Vc
secondary to the increased Pvas as
goes up. A quantitative
expression for these effects (Eq. B6) is also derived in
APPENDIX B. Suppose we again began at FRC with Pvas = 5 cmH2O, Pla = 0 cmH2O, and Cc = 8%/cmH2O. Equation B6 predicts that transit
time would fall to 59 and 35% of its initial value if
doubled
and quadrupled, respectively, rather than to 50 and 25% if Cc were 0. These figures are surprisingly close to the experimental results of
Presson et al. (25), who measured the distribution of RBC
transit times with sequential doublings of pulmonary blood flow and
found reductions in transit time of 60 and 36% when
doubled
and quadrupled,
respectively.2
Changes in PMN transit time. PMNs are larger in diameter than many pulmonary capillaries (7, 18), and, compared with RBCs, they have a wider range of transit times in the pulmonary vasculature and move through at an unsteady rate, stopping for various times in pulmonary capillaries (22). These transit times are determined by a combination of the deformability of PMNs and the baseline diameter and distensibility of the capillaries. Under normal circumstances, the deformability of PMNs is thought to be much greater than that of capillaries (7, 22, 27). However, this does not imply that Cc is not important, because capillary pressures and compliance set the baseline capillary diameters. This interaction between PMNs and capillaries may change greatly in disease in which PMNs exhibit increased stiffness (9) and pulmonary vascular pressures often change considerably. However, the effects of disease on Cc are unknown.
| |
APPENDIX A |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The extraction of
Vc/Vc from optical measurements was
accomplished in two steps. We first determined the diffuse extinction coefficients at two wavelengths, 693 nm and 808 nm. From this pair, we
then determined the fractional changes in blood volume.
To the extent that the typical distances over which we measure optical
intensities (<1.5 cm) are small compared with the radius of curvature
of the pleural surface, and to the extent that there is sufficient
absorption such that the remote boundaries of the lung do not
contribute to scattering amplitudes, the lung can be viewed as a
semi-infinite half space bounded by a plane tangent to the pleural
surface. The theory of diffuse scattering when such a medium is
illuminated with a point source of light has been treated elsewhere
(5, 15). The intensity I falls off sharply with
radial distance r from the optical origin. A rigorous treatment of this phenomenon shows that I(r) is
well approximated by
|
(A1) |
kr/r2, or,
equivalently, ln
I(r)r2 = const
kr. It follows that the linear term in a regression of ln
I(r)r2 vs. r
yields
k. [Note that, in our previous work, we took
kr to be much less than unity, resulting in the use of a
regression of ln I(r)r3
against r to find k. We no longer make this
assumption. Because the exponential function decreases faster than any
power of r, this turns out to make a negligible difference
in the results.] The diffuse extinction coefficients for both
wavelengths were determined by the above method, with intensities
measured at three different locations relative to the optical origin,
namely at 0.396, 0.792, and 1.189 cm.
As argued in Topulos et al. (30), the square of the
diffuse extinction coefficient is an additive function of all absorbing species. From that work, we have
|
(A2) |
is the ratio of L to the geometric mean
linear intercept, A is absorption due to nonblood components
of lung tissue, [Hb] is total hemoglobin concentration in millimoles
per liter, Vc/V is capillary blood volume density (volume blood per
volume lung),
HbO2 and
Hb are
the extinction coefficients for oxygenated and deoxygenated Hb,
respectively (31), and S is mean oxygen saturation. Use of Eq. A2 requires elimination of
the unknown constant
/L, and this can be accomplished in
two ways: if S of blood in the sampled volume is known, one can measure
the differential absorption at two different wavelengths; if S is
unknown, one can add another absorbing species, such as indocyanine
green dye, in known concentrations (30). In the intact
animal, it is not possible to know the saturation of the pulmonary
blood. However, in the excised perfused lung (with essentially no
metabolism), the saturation of all blood can be controlled and
measured, and so the simpler two wavelength calibration method is
possible. In all experiments, lobes were ventilated with 95%
O2, with saturation of all blood in the system effectively
100% at all times. This was confirmed by explicit measurements of both
pulmonary arterial and venous blood. In this case
|
(A3) |
|
(A4) |

=
808 
693. Now
consider the change in k2 associated with
changes in Vc from a reference state, at the isobestic wavelength of
808 nm. From Eq. A3, we have
|
(A5) |
are also fixed. But the unknown factors in
this expression are precisely those related to the change of
k2 with wavelength through differences in
.
Combining Eqs. A4 and A5, we get
|
(A6) |
|
(A7) |
Vc/Vc . Note
that this equation only applies at fixed VL.
Finally, we remark on the choice of the reference state from which
changes in k8082, and hence changes in Vc,
are measured. We chose a vascular pressure of 5 cmH2O
relative to airway pressure as the reference Ptm for all measurements.
That is, by definition,
Vc/Vc = 0 at Ptm = 5 cmH2O. The reference value of
k8082 was estimated by
<k8082>, defined to be the average
value of k8082 over all measurements
where 3 < Ptm < 7 cmH2O. This reference value
was then used to compute the change in the diffuse extinction coefficient needed in Eq. A7 by defining
|
(A8) |
k2 to 
for calibration purposes, also
applies at the reference state, for which we used
|
(A9) |
Vc/Vc is not the
discrete logarithmic differential of the capillary volume, as would be
required for a strict interpretation of this as a volume-specific increment. Rather, it is explicitly the change in volume normalized by
the fixed reference volume
Vc/Vc = (Vc
Vcref)/Vcref. Of course, the compliance
normalized to a reference volume and the specific compliance differ
negligibly near the reference volume; it is only for large departures
therefrom that these are different. Our normalization to a reference
volume has the advantage that, apart from this scaling factor, our
measurements of
Vc/Vc vs. Ptm are the actual P-V curves of the microvasculature.
| |
APPENDIX B |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Changes in
are associated with changes in microvascular
pressure, and a quantitative expression for this relationship can be
derived as follows. The difference (
P) Pvas
Pla, resistance (R) between those sites, and
are related by
P =
R. Nondimensionalize this expression with respect to a reference
state (designated by subscript 0) by defining p =
P/
P0, q =
/
0, and
r = R/R0, in terms of which
|
(B1) |
As
increases, there are two contributions to the increase in
vascular pressure. First, there is the direct effect of q itself for any given r, through the increased flow-resistive
pressure loss. Second, there is the indirect effect associated with a
decrease in r as p increases, secondary to the
increase in capillary volume (and therefore vessel diameter). In
pulmonary capillaries, where the Reynolds and Womersley numbers are
much smaller than 1 (p. 361 in Ref. 11), resistance R is proportional
to the inverse fourth power of the capillary radii (Poiseuille flow),
or, equivalently, to the inverse square of the capillary
cross-sectional areas A. As argued in the text, at fixed
VL, capillary segment lengths are fixed, and all volume
changes occur through proportional changes in area (28);
this model assumes pure distension and no vascular recruitment. It
follows, then, that because R
A
2 and
A
Vc, we have
|
(B2) |
P 
P0)], or
|
(B3) |
P0. Combining
Eqs. B1, B2, and B3 then yields the
relationship between the nondimensional microvascular pressure and
|
(B4) |
; it can be evaluated either numerically or by noting that it is
a simple cubic in p.
This same line of reasoning can be used to estimate the change in
transit times (T) of RBCs with changes in
. We begin
with the elementary relationship T = Vc/
; its
nondimensional equivalent is
|
(B5) |
= T/T0. From
Eqs. B3 and B4, we find
|
(B6) |
, the pressure is found from Eq. B4.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|---|
We thank Sameer Bhalotra, Danielle Boudreau, Ben Fabry, Dan Fitzgerald, Noah Helman, and Kazuko Ryu for technical assistance; Henry Feldman for advice on statistical analysis, and Claire Doerschuk, Stephen Loring, and Wiltz Wagner for helpful discussions.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
This research was supported by National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Grant 55569.
Address for reprint requests and other correspondence: G. P. Topulos, Dept. of Anesthesia, Brigham and Women's Hospital, 75 Francis St., Boston, MA 02115 (E-mail: topulos{at}zeus.bwh.harvard.edu).
1 The design of our experiments kept Ppa ~ Ppv, so the vasculature was in zone I when Ptm < 0 and in zone III when Ptm > 0. The microvasculature may have transiently gone through zone II conditions as Ptm went through zero.
2 Presson et al. (25) reported transit time ratios of 62, 60, and 59% respectively from the distribution modes, the input/output moments, and damped least squares methods in their Table 1 and Fig. 11.
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
Received 28 December 1999; accepted in final form 21 June 2000.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1.
Al-Tinawi, A,
Clough AV,
Harder DR,
Linehan JH,
Rickaby DA,
and
Dawson CA.
Distensibility of small veins of the dog lung.
J Appl Physiol
73:
2158-2165,
1992
2.
Bachofen, H,
Hildebrandt J,
and
Bachofen M.
Pressure-volume curves of air- and liquid-filled excised lungs-surface tension in situ.
J Appl Physiol
29:
422-431,
1970
3.
Barman, SA,
and
Taylor AE.
Effect of pulmonary venous pressure elevation on vascular resistance and compliance.
Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol
258:
H1164-H1170,
1990
4.
Beck, KC,
and
Hildebrandt J.
Adaptation of vascular pressure-flow-volume hysteresis in isolated rabbit lungs.
J Appl Physiol
54:
671-679,
1983
5.
Butler, JP,
Suzuki S,
Oldmixon EH,
and
Hoppin FG, Jr.
A theory of diffuse light scattering by lungs.
J Appl Physiol
58:
89-96,
1985
6.
Clements, J,
Hustead R,
Johnson R,
and
Gribetz I.
Pulmonary surface tension and alveolar stability.
J Appl Physiol
16:
444-450,
1961
7.
Doerschuk, CM,
Beyers N,
Coxson HO,
Wiggs B,
and
Hogg JC.
Comparison of neutrophil and capillary diameters and their relation to neutrophil sequestration in the lung.
J Appl Physiol
74:
3040-3045,
1993
8.
Doerschuk, CM,
Markos J,
Coxson HO,
English D,
and
Hogg JC.
Quantitation of neutrophil migration in acute bacterial pneumonia in rabbits.
J Appl Physiol
77:
2593-2599,
1994
9.
Drost, EM,
Kassabian G,
Meiselman HJ,
Gelmont D,
and
Fisher TC.
Increased rigidity and priming of polymorphonuclear leukocytes in sepsis.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med
159:
1696-1702,
1999
10.
Fishman, AP.
Pulmonary circulation.
In: Handbook of Physiology. The Respiratory System. Circulation and Nonrespiratory Functions. Bethesda, MD: American Physiological Society, 1985, sect. 3, vol. I, chapt. 3, p. 93-165.
11.
Fung, YC.
Biodynamics: Circulation. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1984.
12.
Gillespie, DJ,
and
Hyatt RE.
Respiratory mechanics in the unanesthetized dog.
J Appl Physiol
36:
98-102,
1974
13.
Glazier, JB,
Hughes JM,
Maloney JE,
and
West JB.
Measurements of capillary dimensions and blood volume in rapidly frozen lungs.
J Appl Physiol
26:
65-76,
1969
14.
Godbey, PS,
Graham JA,
Presson RG, Jr,
Wagner WW, Jr,
and
Lloyd TC, Jr.
Effect of capillary pressure and lung distension on capillary recruitment.
J Appl Physiol
79:
1142-1147,
1995
15.
Graaff, R,
Koelink MH,
de Mul FFM,
Zijlstra WG,
Dassel ACM,
and
Aarnoudse JG.
Condensed Monte Carlo simulations for the description of light transport.
Appl Optics
32:
426-434,
1993.
16.
Hildebrandt, J.
Pressure-volume data of cat lung interpreted by a plastoelastic, linear viscoelastic model.
J Appl Physiol
28:
365-372,
1970
17.
Hillier, SC,
Godbey PS,
Hanger CC,
Graham JA,
Presson RG, Jr,
Okada O,
Linehan JH,
Dawson CA,
and
Wagner WW, Jr.
Direct measurement of pulmonary microvascular distensibility.
J Appl Physiol
75:
2106-2111,
1993
18.
Hogg, JC,
McLean T,
Martin BA,
and
Wiggs B.
Erythrocyte transit and neutrophil concentration in the dog lung.
J Appl Physiol
65:
1217-1225,
1988
19.
Hoppin, FGJ,
and
Hildebrandt J.
Mechanical properties of the lung.
In: Bioengineering Aspects of the Lung, edited by West JB.. New York: Dekker, 1977, p. 83-162.
20.
Ingenito, EP,
Mark L,
Morris J,
Espinosa FF,
Kamm RD,
and
Johnson M.
Biophysical characterization and modeling of lung surfactant components.
J Appl Physiol
86:
1702-1714,
1999
21.
Lai, YL,
Rodarte JR,
and
Hyatt RE.
Respiratory mechanics in recumbent dogs anesthetized with thiopental sodium.
J Appl Physiol
46:
716-720,
1979
22.
Lien, DC,
Henson PM,
Capen RL,
Henson JE,
Hanson WL,
Wagner WW, Jr,
and
Worthen GS.
Neutrophil kinetics in the pulmonary microcirculation during acute inflammation.
Lab Invest
65:
145-159,
1991[Web of Science][Medline].
23.
Lien, DC,
Wagner WW, Jr,
Capen RL,
Haslett C,
Hanson WL,
Hofmeister SE,
Henson PM,
and
Worthen GS.
Physiological neutrophil sequestration in the lung: visual evidence for localization in capillaries.
J Appl Physiol
62:
1236-1243,
1987
24.
Linehan, JH,
Haworth ST,
Nelin LD,
Krenz GS,
and
Dawson CA.
A simple distensible vessel model for interpreting pulmonary vascular pressure-flow curves.
J Appl Physiol
73:
987-994,
1992
25.
Presson, RG, Jr,
Hanger CC,
Godbey PS,
Graham JA,
Lloyd TC, Jr,
and
Wagner WW, Jr.
Effect of increasing flow on distribution of pulmonary capillary transit times.
J Appl Physiol
76:
1701-1711,
1994
26.
Reeves, JT,
and
Taylor AE.
Pulmonary hemodynamics and fluid exchange in the lungs during exercise.
In: Handbook of Physiology. Exercise. Regulation and Integration of Multiple Systems. Bethesda, MD: Am. Physiol. Soc, 1996, sect. 12, chapt. 13, p. 585-613.
27.
Schmid-Schonbein, G.
Rheology of leukocytes.
In: Handbook of Bioengineering, edited by Skalak R.,
and Chien S.. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1987, p. 13.16-13.18.
28.
Smith, JC,
and
Mitzner W.
Analysis of pulmonary vascular interdependence in excised dog lobes.
J Appl Physiol
48:
450-467,
1980
29.
Szidon, JP,
and
Flint JF.
Significance of sympathetic innervation of pulmonary vessels in response to acute hypoxia.
J Appl Physiol
43:
65-71,
1977
30.
Topulos, GP,
Lipsky NR,
Lehr JL,
Rogers RA,
and
Butler JP.
Fractional changes in lung capillary blood volume and oxygen saturation during the cardiac cycle in rabbits.
J Appl Physiol
82:
1668-1676,
1997
31.
Van Assendelft, OW.
Spectrophotometry of Haemoglobin Derivatives. Springfield, IL: Thomas, 1970.
32.
Weibel, ER.
The Pathway for Oxygen: Structure and Function in the Mammalian Respiratory System. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1984.
33.
Wiggs, BR,
English D,
Quinlan WM,
Doyle NA,
Hogg JC,
and
Doerschuk CM.
Contributions of capillary pathway size and neutrophil deformability to neutrophil transit through rabbit lungs.
J Appl Physiol
77:
463-470,
1994
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. P. Butler, R. E. Brown, D. Stamenovic, J. P. Morris, and G. P. Topulos Effect of surface tension on alveolar surface area J Appl Physiol, September 1, 2002; 93(3): 1015 - 1022. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. P. Topulos, R. E. Brown, and J. P. Butler Increased surface tension decreases pulmonary capillary volume and compliance J Appl Physiol, September 1, 2002; 93(3): 1023 - 1029. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Visit Other APS Journals Online |