|
|
||||||||
HIGHLIGHTED TOPIC
Reflexes from the Lungs and Airways
1Departments of Physiology and Biophysics, Case Western Reserve University, MetroHealth Medical Center, Cleveland; 2Louis Stokes Cleveland Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Brecksville; and 3Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Department of Medicine, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio
Submitted 1 February 2006 ; accepted in final form 22 August 2006
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
respiration; control of expiration; vagal reflexes
These prior studies, however, generally evaluated the effects of sustained lung inflation [i.e., applied for a time equal to or greater than expiratory duration (TE)]. Pulse lung inflation (i.e., applied for a time less than TE), however, may have quite different effects. More recent studies, in fact, have demonstrated that lung inflations are not entirely facilitatory but that they may also have inhibitory effects (4, 9, 12, 21). For example, although small to moderate lung inflations facilitate, larger lung inflations depress internal intercostal nerve and medullary expiratory neuronal activities (12). These studies suggest that the control of expiratory muscle activation is more complex than originally proposed.
A systematic evaluation of the effects of lung inflation (over a wide range of inflation pressures) on both rib cage and abdominal muscle activation has not been performed. Furthermore, the effects of lung inflation on triangularis sterni activation, a muscle that has been shown to have an important expiratory action (15) are also unknown. It was our hypothesis that pulse lung inflation applied during the expiratory phase generally exerts inhibitory influences on expiratory motor output through vagally mediated reflex effects. Such reflex effects may provide a means of modulating expiratory braking in newborns, allowing maintenance of elevated lung volumes (20).
The purpose of the present study, therefore, was to more closely examine and further characterize the effects of lung inflation applied during the expiratory phase on the control of thoracic and abdominal expiratory motor activities. This was accomplished by assessing the stimulus response relationship between the magnitude of lung inflations applied during the expiratory phase and expiratory chest wall muscle activity. Tests were performed with two types of anesthesia and at various anesthetic levels to differentiate reflex effects, which may be sensitive to anesthesia (17, 31).
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-chloralose (70 mg/kg) and urethane (0.6 mg/kg). Supplemental doses of anesthetic (pentobarbital 12 mg/kg iv in groups 1 and 2 or
-chloralose 20 mg/kg and urethane 0.2 mg/kg iv in group 3) were administered as needed to maintain absent withdrawal reflexes but intact corneal reflexes. All studies were performed in the supine posture. A cuffed endotracheal tube was sutured into the cervical trachea. End-tidal PCO2 was monitored at the tracheal tube opening (CO2 analyzer, Beckman LB-2). Tidal volume was recorded by integrating electrically the flow signal from a pneumotachograph (Fleisch #1). Airway pressure (Paw) at the endotracheal tube was recorded with a pressure transducer (Validyne MP-45) connected to the airway opening. Body temperature was monitored with a rectal probe and maintained with a heating blanket at 38 ± 0.5°C. Catheters were placed in the femoral vein and artery to administer fluids and monitor blood pressure, respectively. Bipolar, Teflon-coated, stainless steel electrodes (0.05 in. diameter) were placed directly into exposed muscles to record their electromyographic (EMG) activities. EMG activity was recorded from the following muscles: triangularis sterni (TS; fourth space), internal intercostal (IIC; ninth or tenth space), and transversus abdominis (TA). Parasternal intercostal EMG (third space) was also recorded to determine the onset and offset of the inspiratory phase. EMG activities were amplified, rectified, and integrated [(time constant: 0.1 s) Charles Ward Enterprises, Ardmore, PA], to obtain moving averages of activity. Airway pressure and integrated parasternal, TS, IIC, and TA EMG activities were recorded on ultraviolet-sensitive paper (Electronics for Medicine, Honeywell, Pleasantville, NY) for subsequent analysis.
Experimental protocol.
The effects of pulse lung inflation (duration 1.01.5 s) on TS, IIC, and TA EMG were examined by varying the magnitude and timing of lung inflation and flow rate independently. Although lung inflations were applied manually with a large-volume syringe, the magnitude of inflation was assessed by the corresponding change in airway pressure. Airflow during lung inflation ranged between 1.5 and 3 l/s unless the effects of airflow were being evaluated. Multiple lung inflations were administered (mean: 30/animal) and a recovery period of 510 breaths elapsed between inflations. Lung inflations of various magnitudes were applied during the plateau of expiratory EMG activity (n = 15, all animals in groups 1 and 3, 6 animals in group 2). The magnitude of lung inflation varied between 2 and 20 cmH2O or
50650 ml.
To assess the effects of timing of applied stimuli during the respiratory cycle, inflations of the same magnitude were delivered at various times throughout the expiratory phase (n = 11, group 2). Because moderate pulse inflation had the most unequivocal response on TS EMG, the effects of timing of lung inflation on expiratory motor output were only evaluated for this muscle.
The effects of different airflow rates on the complex reflex responses observed in the chloralose-urethane-anesthetized animals were evaluated by applying lung inflations of the same magnitude (Paw < 20 cmH2O) at flow rates ranging between 0.1 and 5 l/s (n = 3, group 3).
The role of the vagus nerve in mediating the observed responses was assessed by evaluating the response to lung inflation following bilateral cervical vagotomy. The effects of electrical vagal stimulation on TS expiratory motor activity were also evaluated in six animals (group 2). The central cut end of the vagus nerve was placed on a stimulating electrode in the cervical region. The minimal electrical current necessary to prolong the expiratory phase [methodology for selective activation of reflexes from pulmonary stretch receptors described by Karczewski et al. (27)] was then applied. Threshold current ranged between 50 and 500 µA (lower values for desheathed nerve) as determined with a 0.5-ms pulse duration and a 30-Hz pulse frequency. The percent change in TS EMG in response to 1.5-T (threshold) electrical vagal stimulation with 0.5-ms pulse duration, 100-Hz frequency, and 1.0-s train duration was determined.
Data analysis. Changes in peak EMG activity in response to lung inflation were expressed as a percentage of baseline, which was taken as the average of the three preceding control breaths. In most cases, integrated expiratory activity was constant throughout the expiratory phase. TE was measured from the rapid decline of parasternal intercostal activity to the onset of the next burst of parasternal activity. As with our assessment of EMG activity, changes in TE of the test breath and the timing of pulse lung inflation applied during the test expiratory phase were expressed as percentages of the average of the three preceding control expiratory durations. The relationship between percent change in EMG and Paw was determined for each animal individually. Group mean data were calculated at various levels of airway pressure at 2.5-cmH2O increments. A single point from each animal at each of these Paw values was obtained by averaging all data points between 1.25 cmH2O below and 1.25 cmH2O above that level of pressure (4 or more maneuvers). For changes in TE, 5% increments were assessed in similar fashion. The effects of electrical stimulation of the vagus nerve were expressed as a percent of the control TS EMG and averaged in six animals.
Mean values and SEs were determined. Statistical comparisons were made using t-tests for two paired samples, repeated-measures ANOVA, and regression analysis, where appropriate. A P value of < 0.05 was considered significant.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
-chloralose-urethane is presented in Fig. 2. There were no statistical differences between the slopes of the Paw/EMG relationships between groups 1 and 2 (P > 0.01). The results from both groups therefore are presented together. Over a wide range of inflation pressures, the magnitude of the inhibitory responses of expiratory muscle activities was directly related to the magnitude of lung inflations.
|
0.05) compared with IIC and TA for inflation sizes in the range 5 to 12.5 cmH2O (Fig. 2). For inflation of 5 cmH2O, inhibition of TS was statistically significant (P < 0.05) but changes in IIC and TA were not. These results indicated that TS had the lowest threshold and the most sensitive reflex response to lung inflation. Facilitation of TA in response to small lung inflations was not statistically significant.
The inhibitory response to lung inflation was independent of the rate of inflation. However, inflations with high flow rates (2.55 l/s) occasionally resulted in a short-lasting excitation of IIC just prior to the inhibitory response during
-chloralose-urethane anesthesia.
Effect of timing of lung inflation on expiratory motor activity.
Because TS EMG responded to lung inflation with the lowest threshold and the greatest consistency, this muscle was used to evaluate the effect of timing of lung inflation on expiratory motor activity. For lung inflations of approximately the same size (250300 ml, that which resulted in
50% inhibition of integrated TS EMG activity), the degree of inhibition was unrelated to the time in expiration during which the lung inflation was applied (Fig. 3). Results for an individual animal are shown in Fig. 3A and for the entire group in Fig. 3B.
|
-chloralose-urethane and pentobarbital studies. For small lung inflations in six of nine animals, lung inflation shortened Te in pentobarbital- but not in
-chloralose-urethane-anesthetized animals, resulting in the single data point below control values in Fig. 4. Both relationships showed a good fit to linearity (r > 0.9 for both); intercepts with axis at 100% had positive values for both: 6.5 cmH2O for group 2 and 2.5 cmH2O for group 3.
|
-chloralose-urethane-anesthetized animals.
Effects of vagal stimulation.
Because high-intensity electrical stimulation of the vagus nerve increases the probability of stimulation of afferents other than from pulmonary stretch receptors (20), the effects of vagal stimulation were evaluated only for TS EMG because the threshold for evoking inhibition of TS EMG was much lower than that of IIC. The threshold for IIC EMG inhibition was
1.5 T for TS EMG. Stimulation of the central end of the transected vagus nerve inhibited the magnitude of TS activity in each animal. Increasing intensity of electrical stimulation resulted in progressively greater degrees of inhibition (Fig. 5B). In response to 1.5-T intensity of stimulation (39), the average TS EMG inhibition was 29.67 ± 6.95% of control values (P < 0.0001). The relationship between the intensity of vagal stimulation and the degree of TS inhibition was qualitatively similar to that between lung inflation of different magnitudes and TS inhibition Results from a single experiment to illustrate this similarity are presented in Fig. 5.
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Effects of pulse inflation on the intensity of expiratory motor activity. Both facilitatory and inhibitory effects of lung inflations on the intensity of expiratory motor activity have been described previously. Bishop and Bachofen (7) found that the application of constant positive-pressure breathing and of expiratory threshold loading recruited quiescent abdominal muscles. The amount of this activity increased in proportion to the level of pressure applied during the expiratory phase (6). Polacheck et al. (33) demonstrated that an increase in the amplitude of expiratory activity, in response to lung inflation, is the result of a prolongation of TE rather than increases in the rate of rise or earlier onset of activation. In contrast, other studies have documented inhibition of IIC motor unit potentials (2) and IIC EMG (4) in response to pulse lung inflations.
Similarly, both excitatory and inhibitory effects have been observed in medullary expiratory activity. Small to moderate pulse lung inflations result in increases in expiratory premotor output from the caudal medulla (11, 28). In contrast, caudal (29) and rostral medullary expiratory neurons (4, 19) appear to be inhibited in response to lung inflation applied during the expiratory phase.
The differences in response to lung inflation observed in these previous studies are most likely attributable to variations in duration and inflation magnitude. These previous investigations are consistent with the notions that a continuous increase in vagal stimulation enhances expiratory motor output (6, 35), whereas phasic input decreases expiratory activity depending on the size of stimulus (36). Cohen et al. (12) found that small to moderate inflations facilitated medullary expiratory neuronal and IIC motor activity, but larger inflations depressed activity in unanesthetized decerebrate cats. They compared the effects of inflation magnitude near control inspiration with inflations one-third this size (both of 700-ms duration). In general, large inflations depressed activity, whereas the small inflations facilitated activity. Bajic et al. (4) found similar results in anesthetized dogs and demonstrated a direct relationship between the magnitude of inflation pressure and degree of IIC inhibition. Cohen et al. (12) also showed that an inflation (0.5-s duration) similar in magnitude to that of spontaneous breathing resulted in an initial depression of activity followed by a rebound increase in caudal medullary expiratory neuronal and IIC nerve activity to greater than control levels. Arita and Bishop (2) found that maintained lung inflation evoked an initial silent phase in 6 of 10 animals followed by a prolonged burst of IIC motor unit potentials. The results of Arita and Bishop can be explained by a transient inhibitory effect of lung inflation followed by excitation due to continuously enhanced vagal input and chemical drive as well as a habituation of inhibitory effects.
The results of the present investigation are consistent with and extend the results of these previous studies. We also found that small lung inflations (<7 cmH2O) facilitated TA, whereas larger inflations depressed all expiratory motor activity. Furthermore, our results indicate that there is a differential response of abdominal and rib cage expiratory motor output to changes in vagal input. As suggested by Smith et al. (40), only small lung inflations facilitated TA and inhibited TS EMG muscles. Larger inflations, however, uniformly inhibited the activity of each of these expiratory muscles. In addition, our results also indicate that the degree of TS inhibition by lung inflation is qualitatively similar to that of the IIC; the activities of both IIC and TS muscles were inhibited progressively and in graded fashion by pulse inflations between inflation pressures of 5 and 15 cmH2O. The greater sensitivity of TS EMG to lung inflation, however, suggests that TS activity is more responsive to vagal afferent feedback.
Vagally mediated facilitation and inhibition of expiratory motor activity that is dependent on the magnitude of lung inflation resembles the facilitation and graded inhibition of inspiratory activity that can be recorded prior to the inspiratory off switch (5, 10, 13, 16, 42). In contrast to inspiratory graded inhibition (18), however, expiratory inhibition is not dependent on the timing of vagal stimulation during the expiratory phase.
Effect of anesthesia. Pentobarbital anesthesia was used for purposes of consistency with previously performed studies evaluating the neural control of expiratory muscle activation (see above and also Refs. 15, 41). Inhibition of expiratory motor activity, however, cannot be attributed to pentobarbital anesthesia because inhibition of thoracic expiratory activities has also been observed in decerebrate (12) and awake (1, 40) animals as well.
The transient excitation of IIC muscle activation by inflation with high flow rates was observed only in
-chloralose-urethane- but not in pentobarbital-anesthetized dogs. This transient excitatory reflex may be related to extravagal stretch reflexes (3, 38) because some excitation of IIC EMG was preserved after vagotomy.
Neural pathways involved in the alterations of expiratory motor activation. Although the observed reflex effects are clearly vagally mediated, we can only speculate as to the specific vagal receptors involved in mediating the inhibitory effects on expiratory motor activity. For several reasons, however, our results suggest that pulmonary stretch receptors (PSR) are primarily responsible. First, both the excitatory (on TA with small inflations) and inhibitory effects occurred with the application of modest lung inflations within the physiological operating range of changes in airway pressure. Second, thoracic expiratory inhibition could be reproduced by threshold electrical vagal stimulation that has been shown to selectively activate reflexes from pulmonary stretch receptors (22, 27). Although activation of pulmonary C-fiber receptors has been shown to inhibit expiratory muscle activity (23, 24), the threshold for their activation is higher by one order of magnitude. Third, other studies (4) have demonstrated that the neural responses to step inflations have a relatively slow adaptation rate consistent with pulmonary stretch receptor activation.
Low-intensity electrical vagal stimulation showed no "conditioning" or time relationship between the application of repeated stimuli and the observed response (see Fig. 6). Lack of any potentiation suggests (27, 39) that the inhibitory effect was transmitted by PSR fibers. Studies with the application of SO2 block (14) would be useful to confirm the role of PSR in mediating this reflex.
While previous investigators (4) did find a small degree of time dependency for expiratory bulbospinal neurons in response to step and ramp inflations, the lung inflation stimulus was maintained throughout the expiratory phase in those studies and, therefore, did not allow complete discrimination between timing effects of the stimulus and central motor output. In the present investigations, the same stimulus of short duration was applied at different times within the expiratory phase, allowing its effect on the amplitude of expiratory motor output to be differentiated from mechanisms controlling TE.
Postvagotomy, the enhancement of IIC in response to large inflation (15 cmH2O < Paw < 20 cmH2O) is most likely secondary to activation of spinally mediated stretch reflexes (3, 34). This reflex may decrease the inhibitory effect of large inflation on IIC observed before vagotomy in
-chloralose-urethane-anesthetized animals (Fig. 2).
Functional implications. The potential significance of a reflex inhibition of expiratory motor activity in response to increases in lung volume is unclear. However, it is possible that these responses may defend the respiratory system against rapid increments in airway pressure and changes in functional residual capacity (FRC).
Inhibition of expiratory muscle activity and prolongation of TE in response to large lung expansions may play a role in the mechanism of expiratory braking in infants (30) and serve to optimize expiratory flow patterns. It is well established that newborns require a reflex mechanism that allows them to maintain an elevated FRC. It has been suggested that this mechanism may be consequent to postinspiratory activation (20, 30). Vagally mediated inhibition of expiratory activity would support the dynamic elevation of FRC in infants, in whom vagal reflexes are stronger compared with adults. With prolonged increases in lung volume such as that induced by positive end-expiratory pressure, expiratory activity is eventually facilitated to overcome the load and to preserve ventilation.
| GRANTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. M. Lalley D1/D2-dopamine receptor agonist dihydrexidine stimulates inspiratory motor output and depresses medullary expiratory neurons Am J Physiol Regulatory Integrative Comp Physiol, June 1, 2009; 296(6): R1829 - R1836. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Visit Other APS Journals Online |