|
|
||||||||
INVITED REVIEW
HIGHLIGHTED TOPIC
Physiological Imaging of the Lung
1Department of Anesthesiology and Intensive Care, Karolinska University Hospital Solna; 2Section of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Care Medicine, Department of Physiology and Pharmacology, Karolinska Institutet; 3Section of Nuclear Medicine, Department of Hospital Physics, Karolinska University Hospital Solna; and 4Medical Radiation Physics, Department of Oncology-Pathology, Stockholm University and Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
respiratory physiology; regional blood flow; pulmonary ventilation; pulmonary gas exchange; radionuclide imaging
| SPECT IMAGING |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Emission tomography aims at noninvasive quantification and spatial localization of physiological, metabolic, or pathological processes in humans or animals through the use of a tracer that is either radioactive itself or labeled with a radioactive compound. Characteristics of some commonly used radionuclides are presented in Table 1. Photons emitted from the radiotracer are registered at various angles around the body by a gamma camera. These data are then used for a computational reconstruction of a three-dimensional image of the radioactivity distribution. Thus SPECT compares with planar gamma camera imaging as X-ray computed tomography (CT) with the standard chest X-ray. Typically a registration is done for 1060 s at 6490 consecutive angles over an interval of 360°, i.e., at 45.6° per angle. Nowadays, most SPECT systems use a multiheaded camera to speed up image acquisition, which normally requires 1030 min.
|
Physical interaction with tissues causes scatter and attenuation of photons emitted from the radiotracer, which results in an underestimation of the true concentration of radioactivity within the body. Scattering changes the original direction of photons emitted from the radiotracer, which contributes to image blurring. When photons interact with tissues they lose some of their energy; most scattered photons can therefore be excluded by rejecting photons with a reduced energy. However, the finite energy resolution of the gamma camera means that some scattered (secondary) photons cannot be discriminated from primary photons. When the lung is imaged, the fraction of scattered photons is typically 1015% of all detected photons (71). The amount of attenuation and scatter depends on the photon energy and also on the length and physical properties of the pathway between the emitting radiotracer and the gamma camera. For example, half of the photons from technetium-99m (99mTc) are lost after passing through 4.5 cm of soft tissue (87). Scatter and attenuation are therefore not uniform throughout the body, causing distortion of the image.
Quantitative SPECT requires that measurements are corrected for these image-degrading factors (Fig. 1) (5, 62, 71, 88). One approach to this problem is the use of transmission imaging, which uses the SPECT system and an external radiation source to obtain an attenuation map of the imaged object (5, 9, 71). These data can then be applied to correction algorithms that reduce the influence of attenuation and scattered photons and retrieve the true concentration of radioactivity per unit volume. Phantom studies have demonstrated that these methods provide measurements of regional radiotracer concentrations that differ from the true concentrations within only a few percent (Fig. 1) (71).
|
The spatial resolution of the SPECT method depends on the energy of the radionuclide, the specific SPECT system (essentially the type of collimators), and the distance between the emitting source and the gamma camera. The resolution may be assessed by the full-width half-maximum (FWHM); two point sources can be resolved if the distance between them is at least one FWHM. For a typical SPECT system, this distance is 1020 mm for 140 keV photons (99mTc). Corresponding values for PET systems are 46 mm and for CT or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) systems down to 0.5 mm. With SPECT imaging of the chest, the time required for image acquisition and the constant movements of the lungs and the heart results in a further loss of resolution. The lower resolution of the SPECT method, compared with the other methods, results in a greater impact of the partial volume effect. In short, the partial volume effect means that the measured radiotracer concentration at the center of a volume with uniform concentration is influenced by the surrounding concentration if the volume is smaller than two to three times the FWHM in any direction. Thus measurements of radiotracer concentration in volume elements (voxels) below the spatial resolution will not be independent of the concentration in surrounding voxels. Rather the measurements represent an average for a cluster of juxtapositioned voxels but weighted for the voxel at interest. The partial volume effect also causes a gradual attenuation of the concentration measured at the edge of the volume of radiotracer distribution (edge effect). The finite spatial resolution means that SPECT tends to underestimate the heterogeneity of the imaged process. For example, if both regional lung ventilation and perfusion are imaged, SPECT tends to underestimate the heterogeneity of the ventilation-to-perfusion ratios (66). These principles apply also to other imaging methods, but their impact depends on the spatial resolution of the method.
Limitations of the SPECT Method
An obvious limitation of SPECT is the radiation exposure, which depends on the chosen radionuclide and the process studied. A typical combined ventilation and perfusion lung study using 99mTc exposes the subject to an effective dose of 23 mSv. For comparison, in Scandinavia, the annual exposure to background radiation amounts to 25 mSv. A chest CT done for diagnosing pulmonary embolism exposes the patient to 510 mSv. The effective dose approved for studies of healthy volunteers varies between countries. In Sweden, an effective dose of 5 mSv is approved if the study is considered of significant value, which allows up to four measurements in each subject (65). A further limitation of SPECT is the time required for image acquisition; if the protocol includes transmission imaging, the time required might be 45 min. During this time, the imaged object needs to remain in a fixed position in relation to the camera. In general, the time required for image acquisitions is longer for SPECT than for CT- and PET-based methods. The importance of scatter and attenuation corrections and the finite spatial resolution are limitations that have been discussed above. It is essential to understand that, although sharing the same imaging modality, all SPECT methods have unique features that result from the used radiotracer, the manner in which it is administered, and how images are registered and analyzed. We will exemplify and discuss this further below.
Comparison with Other Methods Imaging Regional Blood Flow and Ventilation
During recent years, SPECT, PET, CT, and MRI techniques have all been employed in new methods that image regional lung blood flow and ventilation (4, 36, 39, 55, 71, 76, 89, 91, 92). These methods differ in their advantages and limitations and should therefore be considered as complementary. Compared with other methods, SPECT is widely spread, and radiotracers are available that are easy to use and comparably inexpensive. Compared with other methods, SPECT suffers from a lower spatial resolution, and the time required for image acquisition is longer than for some alternative methods. However, in contrast with several other methods, SPECT allows simultaneous studies of both regional blood flow and ventilation for the whole lung (45, 66, 71). Both regional blood flow and ventilation can be marked during normal tidal breathing; no breathing maneuver is required. A unique feature of SPECT is that both blood flow and ventilation can be marked using radiotracers that remain fixed in the lung tissue after administration. Even if imaged later, the distributions of the radiotracers correspond to the distribution at the time of administration. This can be taken advantage of to explore the distribution of blood flow and ventilation during conditions that are not otherwise amenable to modern imaging methods. For example, we recently administered macroaggregates to healthy volunteers in a human centrifuge to explore the effect of hypergravity on the distribution of lung blood flow (65).
Of note is that imaging methods provide estimates of, e.g., regional lung blood flow or ventilation, expressed in units with different denominators, such as unit lung volume, unit lung tissue, or unit alveolar gas volume. Measurements obtained with different methods might be poorly comparable since the amount of lung tissue or the alveolar gas volume per unit lung volume varies between lung regions and with changes in body posture, lung volume, mode of ventilation, etc. SPECT measurements are generally expressed per unit lung volume, which complicates the comparison of images of blood flow or ventilation obtained during different conditions if the distribution of lung tissue varies with the condition (67). A further use of radiotracers that remain fixed in the lung after administration is that regional blood flow and ventilation can be marked repeatedly (at different occasions) during different conditions, e.g., postures or ventilator settings, while the conditions can be identical for all image acquisitions (67). With this study design, image comparison is simplified since tissue distribution can be assumed to be identical in all images. Another advantage, when all images are obtained with identical tissue distribution, is that the image-degrading effects of scatter, attenuation, and the finite resolution do not contribute to differences between images.
Imaging More Than One Process
The same radionuclide can be used to image two processes sequentially or to repeat imaging of the same process, if either the physical decay or the clearance of the radiotracer is very rapid (63). In this case the number of studies is limited by the radiation dose. Other radiotracers can be used for repeated imaging within a short time span using image subtraction (54, 60, 65). With this approach, the radioactivity that remains from the first radiotracer administration is subtracted from the images obtained after the second experiment, which provides the distribution of the radiotracer at the second administration. This requires that images are obtained both before and after the second administration and that the imaged object remain in a fixed position in relation to the camera throughout the procedure. The second dose of the radiotracer should be adjusted so that the majority of the imaged radioactivity originates from the second administration. A further alternative is to use two radiotracers labeled with different energies (dual-isotope imaging), which allows two processes to be marked and imaged simultaneously (45, 66, 71, 72).
| SPECT IMAGING OF REGIONAL LUNG PERFUSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Regional lung blood flow is typically imaged using intravenous administration of macroaggregates of albumin (MAA) labeled with 99mTc. The size of these particles (10150 µm) causes them to become trapped in the pulmonary microcirculation in proportion to regional blood flow, which has been confirmed with other measurement methods (52). A maximum dose of MAA corresponds to
700,000 particles, which occludes <1 x 104% of the pulmonary capillaries (Mallinckrodt Medical, Petten, The Netherlands); according to one manufacturer the particles have a biological half-life of 11 h (Mallinckrodt Medical). With planar gamma camera imaging, regional blood flow has also been studied using intravenous bolus injection of radioactive gases that is allowed to evolve into the alveoli during breathhold (58). The time required for image registration excludes the use of this technique for SPECT. A few SPECT studies have used alternative techniques such as steady-state infusion of krypton-81m (81mKr) (63). The extremely short half-life of this radionuclide (13 s) means that the regional concentration is mostly determined by regional delivery, i.e., blood flow. However, it has been demonstrated that regional measurements of blood flow obtained with this technique are influenced by regional ventilation abnormalities (18).
Posture and the Distribution of Lung Blood Flow
Maeda et al. (50) pioneered the use of SPECT to explore the effect of body posture on the distribution of pulmonary blood flow in healthy volunteers. When administering the macroaggregates with subjects in the upright posture and imaging the distribution with subjects in supine position, they observed a gravitational gradient with increasing blood flow from apex to the base of the lung. In the prone and supine posture, the cranial-to-caudal blood flow distribution was uniform. Similar results have been reported by other SPECT studies (5). These results are consistent with the zonal model (94), which explains a greater blood flow to dependent lung regions with the influence of gravity. SPECT studies of healthy volunteers have demonstrated greater blood flow to dependent (dorsal) regions also in the supine posture (5, 44, 50, 54, 60, 63). In the prone posture the results have been more divergent, with studies showing either a uniform vertical blood flow (60) or greater blood flow to either dependent (50, 63) or nondependent regions (54). Including very few subjects (50, 63), image acquisition in different postures (54, 60), analyzing distributions within the whole lung or only within a section of the lung, and comparing blood flow between regions of equal or nonequal size (54, 60) are all differences between studies that might contribute to varying results.
Blood Flow Variation Within Isogravitational Planes
In a series of studies, Hakim and coworkers used SPECT to demonstrate a heterogeneous distribution of lung blood flow within isogravitational planes in both animals and humans (31, 33, 34, 48). A gradient with decreasing flow from central to peripheral regions was demonstrated both in humans and in excised dogs lungs; in the latter case the gradient was also observed when a section of the lung was studied using planar imaging (32, 48). This is of importance since it showed that the phenomenon was not solely due to SPECT underestimating flow to peripheral regions (edge effect). Hakim et al. (31, 32) concluded that other factors besides gravity, possibly regional vascular conductance, must be of importance for the regional distribution of pulmonary blood flow.
Active Regulation of Lung Blood Flow
In a recent study, Rimeika et al. (70) used SPECT to demonstrate that local production of nitric oxide (NO) influences the distribution of lung blood flood in normal subjects. In the supine posture inhibition of NO synthase caused a redistribution of blood flow from dorsal to ventral regions. On the other hand, inhibition of NO production in the prone posture caused no change in the distribution of regional blood flow.
| SPECT IMAGING OF REGIONAL VENTILATION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Both radioactive gases, mostly krypton-81m (81mKr) and xenon-133 (133Xe), and particulate aerosols labeled with radioactivity have been used for SPECT imaging of regional ventilation. Each of these carries specific advantages and limitations; radiotracers useful for diagnostic imaging are not always equally suited for quantitative measurements. Regional radiotracer concentration after aerosol administration is a result of regional delivery and retention of aerosol particles, which does not necessarily equal regional ventilation.
Radioactive gases. The use of a radioactive gas diminishes concerns that the distribution of the radiotracer might be different from the distribution of regional ventilation; however, it also creates limitations. The rapid decay of 81mKr (half-life = 13 s) means that regional concentration of radioactivity during steady-state inhalation is proportional to regional ventilation (7, 8, 26). However, at increased minute ventilation and in children, regional concentration of the radiotracer is influenced not only by regional ventilation but also by regional alveolar volume (8, 19). The methodology requires that imaging is done during continuous administration of the radiotracer. The cost and the short half-life of the 81mKr generator (4.5 h) limit the use of this radiotracer. 133Xe has a much longer half-life (5.3 days), regional concentration during steady-state inhalation is therefore a reflection of regional gas volume. However, dynamic SPECT, e.g., repetitive 30-s image acquisitions of the whole lung, during the washout phase after steady-state inhalation can been used to study regional ventilation (80). This technique has mostly been used to study abnormalities in regional ventilation in patients with obstructive lung disease (73, 7881). The low energy of 133Xe (80 keV) results in a spatial resolution lower than that for 99mTc and 81mKr.
99mTc-diethylenetriamine pentaacetate aerosol. Clinically the most common ventilation radiotracer is 99mTc-diethylenetriamine pentaacetate (DTPA) aerosol. The aerosol is comparably inexpensive, easy to use, and available at most nuclear medicine departments. Modern nebulizers produce an aerosol with an aerodynamic mass median diameter close to 1.0 µm, which is consistent with a predominating alveolar deposition (13, 47). However, impaction of the aerosol particles in central airways might be a problem, especially in situations with turbulent flow or greater flow velocities (16, 20). Several studies using planar imaging have found that the deposition of the radioaerosol differs from the distribution of regional ventilation measured with 81mKr (1, 16, 20). We are not aware of studies that used SPECT to compare the distribution of 81mKr and DTPA aerosol. A further problem with the 99mTc-DTPA aerosol is that the activity is cleared from the lung by absorption through the alveolar-capillary membrane at a rate that might cause distortion of the images. In fact, the clearance of 99mTc-DTPA has been used to quantify lung injury (61). In normal nonsmoking subjects, Monaghan et al. (53) found a mean half-clearance time of 52 min (range 20132 min); in diseased lung this was reduced to 5 min (range 226 min). In contrast, animal studies of irradiation and amiodaron-induced lung injury have shown a retarded clearance (2, 24, 77, 90). Clinical studies after radiotherapy against the thorax and of amiodaron-induced pulmonary toxicity have, however, found increased DTPA clearance (23, 83, 84, 99). DTPA aerosols with larger particle sizes have been used to study the distribution of inhaled aerosols within the airways (25, 59).
Technegas. Another alternative for SPECT imaging of regional ventilation is Technegas, a dispersion of ultrafine graphite particles labeled with 99mTc (15). The aerosol is produced by a Technegas generator, which heats a graphite crucible with pertechnetate to 2,500°C in an atmosphere of 100% argon. Although there is some disagreement regarding the particle size, most authors agree that the diameter is <200 nm (15, 37, 46, 49, 75); some suggest much smaller. The smaller particle size compared with other aerosols results in a greater alveolar deposition and less impaction in central airways. Several studies, using planar gamma camera imaging, have found 81mKr and Technegas images of regional ventilation to be highly equivalent (6, 20, 22), even during conditions when 99mTc-DTPA aerosol suffered from significant deposition in central airways (20). However, pharmacologically induced bronchoconstriction increases the deposition in central airways, resulting in different distributions of Technegas and 81mKr (64). Technegas deposition in central airways in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease has also been reported in some clinical studies (21, 38). Hinz et al. (35) found a good correlation between SPECT measurements of regional ventilation obtained with Technegas and 81mKr in an animal model of acute lung injury. A special concern with the use of Technegas is that presence of oxygen at the time of combustion leads to contamination with Pertechnegas (74, 98). These particles permeate the alveolar-capillary barrier and are cleared very rapidly from the lung (half-life = 10 min), which will cause a distortion of images acquired during this phase. In contrast, after administration of Technegas the reduction of radioactivity in the lung is almost entirely explained by physical decay (15). Contamination with Pertechnegas is easily detected if the change in radioactivity in the lung is followed during the first 2030 min after Technegas administration. Pertechnegas has been used for measurement of the permeability of the alveolar-capillary membrane (53). Recent work has shown that modification of the Technegas generation process eliminates Pertechnegas contamination, minimizes leach of radioactivity from the particles, and reduces the growth of the particles through aggregation and absorption of water (56). Human studies have found that the retention of these particles within the lung during the first 2470 h after administration is nearly complete (95, 96). Technegas is not approved by the US Food and Drug Administration.
Posture and Regional Ventilation
Several SPECT studies of spontaneously breathing healthy volunteers have demonstrated greater regional ventilation in dependent (dorsal) regions in the supine posture (54, 63). In the prone posture two previous studies have found greater ventilation in nondependent (dorsal regions) (54, 63). In a small number of subjects, Orphanidou et al. (63) also showed that the distribution of ventilation was uniform in the cranial-to-caudal direction in the supine and prone postures, which is in agreement with previous studies.
Airway Closure
Studying normal subjects, King et al. (41, 42) used SPECT to demonstrate a close correlation between the lung volume without radioactivity after inhalation of a bolus of Technegas from residual lung volume and closing capacity measured with a single-breath nitrogen test. In normal subjects, regions affected by airway closure were contiguous and mostly located in dependent regions, while a patchy distribution was observed in asthmatic subjects (42).
Ventilation Heterogeneity
Several recent SPECT studies have evaluated objective estimates of ventilation heterogeneity in normal and diseased lung (57, 97). For example, Xu et al. (97) showed that intra- and interregional ventilation heterogeneity discriminated between normal and emphysematous lungs.
| SPECT IMAGING OF REGIONAL VENTILATION-TO-PERFUSION RATIOS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| SPECT IMAGING OF REGIONAL BLOOD FLOW AND VENTILATION DURING CLINICAL INTERVENTIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Mure et al. (54) explored the effect of continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) and posture on regional lung blood flow and ventilation in normal subjects. CPAP induced a ventilation-perfusion mismatch in both postures, but the effect was greater in the prone posture. In supine position, CPAP caused a redistribution of both blood flow and ventilation to dependent (dorsal) regions. In prone position, blood flow was again shifted to dependent (ventral regions) while ventilation was redistributed to nondependent (dorsal) regions.
Mechanical Ventilation and General Anesthesia
Tokics et al. (85, 86) employed both SPECT, CT, and the multiple inert gas elimination technique (MIGET) to increase our understanding of the gas-exchange impairment induced by general anesthesia and mechanical ventilation. CT demonstrated that general anesthesia causes atelectasis in the dependent lung regions. SPECT showed that these regions were not ventilated but still perfused. Moreover, estimates of shunt obtained by either SPECT or MIGET correlated with the amount of atelectasis. MIGET measurements also showed that the matching of ventilation to perfusion deteriorated during mechanical ventilation compared with when subjects were awake and breathing spontaneously. SPECT showed that during mechanical ventilation (supine) regional ventilation was preferentially distributed to nondependent regions while blood flow was greater in dependent regions.
Effect of the Prone Position in Acute Lung Injury
Lamm et al. (45) used a dual-isotope SPECT method to explore the mechanisms by which the prone position improves oxygenation in an animal model of acute lung injury. In the supine posture the impaired oxygenation was mostly explained by dorsal lung regions with a low ventilation-to-perfusion ratio. Turning the animals prone improved the ventilation-to-perfusion ratio in dorsal regions and reduced the overall ventilation-to-perfusion dispersion, which resulted in a great increase in arterial oxygenation. A previous study using the same animal model demonstrated a similar distribution of blood flow in the supine and prone postures (3). The authors therefore concluded that the major effect of the prone posture is an improved ventilation of dorsal lung regions.
| RECENT INNOVATIONS AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A recent innovation is the introduction of combined SPECT-CT scanners, which provides both functional and anatomical images (Fig. 2). With these systems, CT images provides additional morphological information, e.g., regarding the localization of a disease process, that can be linked to the functional information obtained from the SPECT images. CT images can also replace transmission images used for attenuation corrections. An alternative approach to multimodality imaging is to digitally fuse images obtained with different techniques at different occasions (29, 40, 82).
|
The constant movement of the lung during image acquisition reduces the spatial resolution. Image registration gated to end-inspiration has been shown to increase the diagnostic yield of SPECT imaging (82). Although not yet demonstrated, it is likely that this technique would improve quantitative imaging of regional blood flow and ventilation.
Micro-SPECT
Another recent development is the construction of SPECT systems dedicated for the functional studies of small animals (11, 17, 28). Application of pin-hole collimator techniques and the proximity of the imaging field to the camera result in a spatial resolution that allows imaging of radiotracer distributions even in small objects. In the mouse, structures down to a size of 0.5 mm have been clearly visualized (11), suggesting that molecular uptakes in volumes down to 0.1 µl can be estimated (11). Together with molecular imaging techniques (12, 30), these systems open up new fields of exciting physiological imaging.
| SUMMARY |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
/
ratios in humans by use of PET. II. Procedure and normal values. J Appl Physiol 66: 19051913, 1989.
/
distribution and correlation to atelectasis in anesthetized paralyzed humans. J Appl Physiol 81: 18221833, 1996.