|
|
||||||||
Concord Field Station, Department of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts
Submitted 8 December 2005 ; accepted in final form 22 June 2006
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
locomotion; oxygen consumption; muscle strain; electromyography
There are several factors that influence how much force a given volume of muscle can produce, such as the time course of activation, operating length, and contractile velocity (33, 37). Kinematic patterns have traditionally been used to infer underlying muscle contractile patterns, where changes in kinematics during loading experiments presumably reflect changes in the contractile behavior of the muscles. In studies in which there was no change in kinematics, it has been assumed that operating length and shortening velocities of the leg muscles were unaltered by load carrying (30, 46). However, in cases where time of contact increased with load (32, 38), it is possible that leg muscles shorten more slowly. A reduced shortening velocity would allow a muscle to produce more force, helping to offset the increase in muscle recruitment required to carry a load. It is also possible that under an increased external load, muscles may be actively stretched to a greater extent than during unloaded conditions, further enhancing muscle force output (1, 17, 23, 31, 33. To our knowledge, the effect of load carrying on muscle strain pattern has not been directly measured. The purpose of this study was to explore how trunk loading influences muscle contractile patterns (active stretch and shortening velocity), limb kinematics, and metabolic cost in guinea fowl during treadmill exercise.
In several studies, general kinematic patterns have been measured to determine whether subjects altered their mechanics in response to the load carried. In many cases there was little or no significant change in the time of foot contact with the ground or duty factor (9, 15, 30, 36, 42, 46), and oxygen consumption increased in nearly direct proportion to the increase in load carried. However, other studies have shown that stride frequency (9, 13, 48) and ground contact time (32, 38) may increase slightly during load carriage, and, interestingly, in these cases the increase in oxygen consumption rate (
O2) was less than one to one with respect to the load carried. In a recent loading study, Marsh et al. (38) showed that guinea fowl also increase their time of contact a small, but significant amount (4%), when carrying a trunk load, and this corresponded to an increase in metabolic rate that was 77% of the load carried.
In this study we chose to examine the contractile behavior of the iliotibialis lateralis pars postacetabularis (ILPO) and the medial head of the gastrocnemius (MG), which are both known to be active predominately during the support phase of the locomotor cycle (25). These are also two of the larger hindlimb muscles of guinea fowl. We sought to test the hypothesis that a decrease in muscle fascicle strain rate (shortening velocity) and/or enhanced stretch activation of the muscles would reduce locomotor energy cost relative to the load carried. This reflects the fact that both a slower shortening velocity and force enhancement via active stretch likely reduce a muscle's cost of generating force (33, 37, 40). We propose that changes in kinematics, such as an increase in time of foot contact at a given speed, may enable this reduction in fascicle shortening rate, thereby allowing the muscles to more economically generate the forces required for weight support.
In the absence of changes in muscle contractile patterns and limb kinematics, assuming that muscle forces are distributed relative to their cross-sectional area (i.e., they produce equal stress; Refs. 2, 4, 30, 44), we predicted that the increase in recruitment in these muscles would be proportional to the added load relative to the animal's weight. We quantified muscle recruitment in terms of EMG intensity, because EMG intensity has been shown to correlate well with direct measurements of muscle force in guinea fowl (14). We assumed that the increase in metabolic cost due to a trunk load would be proportional to the cost of producing force to support weight during the stance phase of a stride. On the basis of recent work showing that the relative metabolic cost of swinging the limbs constitutes
25% of the total cost of locomotion (18, 28, 39, 41), we predicted that the relative increase in metabolic cost would be
75% of the relative increase in weight due to the trunk load carried.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Three animals (average mass 1.32 ± 0.02 kg) were selected at random for the metabolic energy studies. These animals were trained to run on a motorized treadmill (Proform, Logan, UT, model PFTL 08040, belt: 0.4 m wide, 1.0 m long) with and without a load of 0.286 kg (on average this represented 21.7% of the animals' mean body weight, which we report hereafter as
22% to reflect the slight variation among animals) supported over their back. The load consisted of a pack constructed of small lead grains in three plastic bags. These were wrapped in elastic tape such that two of the bags hung symmetrically on either side of the bird with the third centered over the bird's back. The packs were positioned approximately over the animals' center of mass (just anterior to the synsacrum as determined from a frozen specimen) and secured with VetWrap. The VetWrap was worn in both loaded and unloaded trials. The animals ran 34 days/wk for 6 wk before data collection. Each training session consisted of three to five runs with and without the load, at speeds of 0.5, 1.0, and 1.5 m/s, each lasting for 5 min. At the time of data collection, each bird could comfortably maintain the highest speed while running with a 22% body weight load for 5 min.
Five animals (average mass 1.31 ± 0.07 kg), including two used in the metabolic trials, were selected for in vivo muscle measurements. The three animals not used to obtain metabolic rate data were trained using the same protocol for 34 wk before surgery and experimental muscle recordings.
Metabolic rate measurements.
Measurements of
O2 were collected by using an open-circuit indirect calorimetry system (24) while the animals walked or ran in a clear Plexiglas box (0.64 x 0.33 x 0.23 m) that was only open to the room at its base as it slid over the moving treadmill belt. A mass flow pump (Flow-Kit model 500H, Sable Systems International, Las Vegas, NV) pulled air from the front of the box at a rate of 55 l/min. This rate was high enough to ensure that all expired gas from the animal was collected. A subsample of the mixed expired air was pulled from the main air flow at 200 ml/min and passed through two columns filled with Drierite and Ascarite to remove water and CO2, respectively. Oxygen content was analyzed using a Sable Systems PA-1B Oxygen Analyzer (Sable Systems International). The system was calibrated using nitrogen at a known flow rate (V Series 16-bit volumetric gas flowmeter, Alicat Scientific, Tucson, AZ) following Fedak et al. (24), which enabled the calculation of
O2. Accuracy of the flow system was found to be within ±1%.
All trials lasted a minimum of 5 min, and oxygen consumption was measured throughout the trial.
O2 was determined from the last minute of the trial when it was clear that oxygen consumption had reached steady state. Speeds (0.5, 1.0, and 1.5 m/s) and loading conditions were randomized, and trials for each condition were collected on different days, with no more than three trials being collected from any one animal on a single day to ensure that the animals were sufficiently well rested to readily perform the exercise. All
O2 values measured were below the maximal rate of oxygen consumption for guinea fowl (20). Resting
O2 values were collected as the guinea fowl sat quietly for 10 min inside the box darkened with a towel covering before exercise trials were conducted. Data were collected at 100 Hz using a 12-bit analog-to-digital (A/D) converter (Digidata 1200B system, Axon Instruments, Union City, CA) and analyzed using AxoScope software (v 8.2, Axon Instruments). Metabolic power was calculated from
O2 assuming an equivalence of 20.1 J/ml O2 (8).
Muscles. To evaluate support phase muscle function, we sampled EMG and fascicle strain from two major limb extensors: the ILPO and the MG (Fig. 1). The ILPO is the largest muscle in the hindlimb; it originates on the dorsolateral iliac crest, the terminal iliac process, and the posterior ischium and inserts on the patellar tendon, giving it an extensor moment at both the hip and knee (25). The MG is primarily an ankle extensor, with the majority of its origin arising from the tibiotarsus; however, a small portion of the MG originates on the patellar tendon, acting to extend the knee as well. EMG studies have shown that both of these muscles are predominately active during stance (25). In addition, recent blood flow studies have shown that these two muscles, along with a few other muscles in the leg, receive a disproportionate increase in blood flow, relative to their mass, during exercise (21, 39) and during trunk loading (22).
|
Each pair of 2.0-mm piezoelectric SONO crystals (Sonometrics, London, ON, Canada) was implanted in the muscles by forming two small pockets in the muscle with the tips of a sharp pair of scissors. The pockets were spaced
1015 mm apart and were arranged parallel to the muscle fascicles. Because the MG is a unipennate muscle, the depths of the crystals were adjusted to match the pennation angle of the muscle. After insertion, the crystals were aligned to maximize their signal-to-noise ratio by monitoring their output on an oscilloscope. Once a good signal (high signal-to-noise ratio) was obtained, the opening was sutured, and the lead wires were anchored to the surface of the muscle belly by use of 4-0 silk suture. In the ILPO, the crystals were implanted in the middle third of the muscle belly, whereas in the MG the crystals were implanted midbelly, spanning most of the muscle fascicles' length (Fig. 1).
Two fine-wire bipolar EMG electrodes (offset twist hook, 0.5-mm bared tips with 1-mm spacing) were inserted into each muscle adjacent to the placement of the SONO crystals, using a 21-gauge hypodermic needle and secured to the muscle belly with 4-0 suture near their insertion site. The EMG electrodes were constructed from insulated fine silver wire (0.1-mm diameter, California Fine Wire, Grover Beach, CA). After all electrodes were implanted, the skin incisions were closed with 3-0 suture and the connector plug anchored above the hip. The wing feathers were trimmed so they did not obscure the limb, joint centers of rotation were palpated, and nontoxic white paint was applied and marked with black ink for obtaining basic joint kinematic data. The animals were administered an analgesic and antibiotics and given 24 h to recover.
In vivo data and video collection.
In vivo muscle data were collected while the animals walked or ran on a motorized treadmill (Woodway USA, Waukesha, WI) over a speed range from 0.5 to 3.0 m/s in 0.5 m/s increments, with and without a 0.286 kg (
22% body wt) load. During data collection, a lightweight shielded cable ran between the external connector attached above the animal's hip and the recording equipment. Outputs from the EMG electrodes were amplified x 1,000 and filtered (10-Hz to 10-kHz band pass) by using Grass P511 preamplifiers (Grass-Telefactor, West Warwick, RI). Signals from the SONO crystals were connected to a sonomicrometry amplifier (Triton 120.2, Triton Technology, San Diego, CA) and monitored via an oscilloscope (Tektronix 2235A, Tektronix Texas, LLC, Richardson, TX). Outputs from the SONO and EMG amplifiers were sampled at 5 kHz by use of a 12-bit A/D converter (Digidata 1200B system, Axon Instruments) and stored on a personal computer. High-speed video (250 Hz, Photron Fastcam-X 1280 PCI; Photron USA, San Diego, CA) was recorded from the lateral view simultaneously with muscle measurements and was synchronized to the muscle recordings via a posttrigger pulse that stopped the video and was recorded by the A/D converter.
Muscle length change and shortening velocity. Fractional changes in muscle fascicle length were determined following Biewener and Corning (5). The sonomicrometry signals were corrected for the offset error introduced by the faster speed of sound propagation through the epoxy lens of the crystals relative to the muscle (determined to be 0.82 mm for the Sonometrics 2.0-mm crystals) and for the 5-ms delay introduced by the Triton 120.2 amplifier's filter. Changes in distance between crystal pairs were normalized to muscle fascicle strain by dividing by a rest length recorded when the animals stood quietly. Fascicle strain recorded locally within the region of the muscle sampled was assumed to be indicative of the full length of the fascicle, as well as the entire muscle. In the MG, this is more likely the case, as the crystal spacing spanned the majority of the fascicles' length. Given the complex architecture of the ILPO, this may not be as valid an assumption. Preliminary results (10) have shown that some regional differences in fascicle strain within the ILPO occur during unloaded locomotion. Despite this possibility, we assume here that changes in strain pattern due to loading observed locally at the sampling site are representative for the whole muscle.
In vivo data from unloaded and loaded conditions were analyzed for four speeds: 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, and 3.0 m/s. This speed range was selected because it includes all of the speeds for which metabolic data were collected, as well as the highest speed for which we were able to obtain recordings from the animals during steady running. For each condition, five strides were selected for analysis and were used to create individual means for each variable. Foot-on and foot-off times were determined from the video data. Strain patterns observed in each muscle were separated into regions of shortening and lengthening based on inflections in the pattern throughout the stride cycle. Because we were primarily interested in muscle strain during stance, mean fascicle strain rates were measured by dividing the highest magnitude strains recorded during stance by the time over which they occurred.
Kinematics. Ten consecutive strides were selected from the video data for kinematic analysis. Stride time, stance time, and swing time were determined for all speeds and conditions (at 250 Hz, errors in time are likely to average one frame, or 0.004 s). A subset of three trials from unloaded and loaded conditions at 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, and 3.0 m/s (for a total of 24 trials) was selected from these data for more detailed joint kinematic analysis. Markers at the posterior iliac process, hip, knee, ankle, and tarsometatarsal-phalangeal joints were digitized by use of a customized MATLAB (v.6.5, The MathWorks, Natick, MA) routine (coded by T. L. Hedrick, University of Washington) and filtered by a quintic spline fit to known root mean square data, using the generalized cross-validatory/spline (GCVSPL) program (49). Because of the skin movement over the knee during locomotion, the coordinates of the knee joint were calculated by generating the equations for circles centered at the coordinates of hip and ankle, with the length of the femur and tibiotarsus being their radii, respectively. The knee joint location was determined by the intersection point of these two circles that most closely matched the digitized knee point. The other intersection point was always clearly incorrect. These coordinates were used to calculate mean joint angles at the hip, knee, and ankle throughout the stride.
EMG analysis. EMG data were analyzed for the same five strides selected for muscle fascicle strain analysis. Several variables were quantified for each signal, including onset time relative to foot-on, duration, and intensity. EMG burst onset and offset were determined by eye, and EMG intensity for a single burst of activation was determined by averaging the spike amplitude of the rectified EMG signal. EMG intensities were then converted to a relative scale for each muscle by dividing this value by the largest value recorded in that muscle for that animal. Thus, for a given animal, the largest burst intensity recorded in a given muscle was assigned the value of 1, and all other bursts from that muscle ranged between 0 and 1 (26). Two EMG electrodes were implanted in each muscle to ensure that at least one reliable signal was recorded. In cases in which both EMG electrodes provided signals, the values for the two signals were averaged.
Statistics. The effects of speed and load were assessed by a mixed-model ANOVA, which included individual as a factor. A general linear model that included first order interaction effects was used to determine significant differences in muscle fascicle strain and strain rate, as well as EMG intensity and timing variables. All tests were conducted in Systat (version 10.2 for PC) with a significance level of P < 0.05. Population means for each variable were calculated from the average for each individual, and are reported with standard errors, unless otherwise noted.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
22% body wt trunk load at each speed (Fig. 2A; P < 0.001). For both unloaded and loaded conditions, metabolic power increased linearly with speed over the range measured. The ratio of loaded to unloaded metabolic power was not significantly different between speeds and averaged 1.17 ± 0.02 (Fig. 2B). The load carried by the birds yielded a loaded to unloaded weight ratio of 1.22 ± 0.02; thus the increase in metabolic energy rate at each speed represented 77% of the increase in weight.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our results show that, when guinea fowl were loaded with
22% of their body weight, their limb kinematics did not change at any given speed. Although no significant changes in shortening velocity of the ILPO and MG were observed, active fascicle stretch during early stance increased in both muscles at nearly all speeds during loaded conditions. Increased active stretching enhances force production (40) and, as a result, likely increases a muscle's economy for generating force (6, 45). For the two muscles we examined, the increase in force required to carry the additional load was also clearly achieved through an increase in muscle recruitment, as indicated by an increase in EMG intensity. In the ILPO, the increase in EMG intensity was less than proportional to the increase in weight; supporting our interpretation that force enhancement via stretch may facilitate the ILPO's force production. In the MG, the increase in EMG intensity was greater than proportional to the load. The collective results from EMG analysis and metabolic energetics suggest that, on average, increases in leg muscle recruitment during stance are proportional to increases in trunk-supported weight.
Kinematics.
On the basis of previous work (15, 30, 36, 42, 46), our null hypothesis was that kinematics would not be significantly changed during load carrying. However, on the basis of the observations that some animals and humans alter their kinematic patterns to some degree when carrying a load (9, 13, 32, 38, 48), we proposed that muscle function might also be altered under these conditions. In this study, we found no significant changes in time of contact and only small changes in joint angle kinematics due to an
22% body load at any speed. This differs slightly from recent observations of Marsh et al. (38) in a similar load-carrying study of guinea fowl, who found a small 4% increase in time of contact. In the present study, we also observed a slight decrease in knee extension during stance; however, this was only significant at the two fastest speeds measured (Fig. 4). Thus our kinematic results support the null hypothesis of our study. It should be pointed out that all of the animals in our study underwent a relatively long training period and were well accustomed to running with the added load at the time of data collection. It is possible that greater differences in kinematics would be observed when the animals carried the load for the first time.
Muscle strain and strain rate. One of the primary goals of our study was to determine whether muscle contractile strain pattern was influenced by load carrying. Specifically, would changes in contractile strain pattern reduce a muscle's cost for generating force? Two possibilities were examined: lower strain rate and increased stretch at onset of muscle activation. Consistent with the results for time of foot contact, we found no significant changes in fascicle shortening rate due to load (Fig. 7). The reduction in knee extension during loaded running at higher speeds was associated with a trend toward reduced fascicle shortening in the ILPO (Fig, 6), which was significant at the highest speed. However, the duration of muscle shortening decreased during this time as well, resulting in mean shortening velocities that were not significantly different between loaded and unloaded conditions. Importantly, however, we observed a significant increase in the degree of active fascicle stretch early in limb support during knee and ankle flexion. The magnitude of fascicle stretch increased under loaded conditions at all speeds in the ILPO and all except at the slowest speed in the MG (Fig. 7). Active stretch of whole muscles and isolated muscle fibers generate more force per unit muscle (1, 17, 23, 31, 33), with the amount of force enhancement being shown to be rate dependent. Thus both the increased magnitude (Fig. 6) and rate (Fig. 7) of stretch of the ILPO suggest that the muscle produces more force per active volume of recruited fibers during loaded vs. unloaded exercise conditions. The magnitude of force enhancement due to stretch remains uncertain but is likely to range up to 1.75 times a muscle's isometric force (3, 7, 16, 23). In addition to our hypothesis that active stretching at the beginning of stance may serve to improve a muscle's force output, Marsh (37) suggested that it may also play a role in providing stability. Thus, despite finding no change in limb kinematics, our hypothesis that this would correspond to no changes in muscle contractile pattern is unsupported. Given the complex interplay of muscle-tendon force transmission and length change, perhaps this is not surprising.
The fascicle strain patterns of both the ILPO (Fig. 4) and the MG (Fig. 5) for normal and load-carriage conditions indicate that the two muscles contract with limited length change (isometric) during the stance phase of the stride at slower speeds, or with increasingly stretch-shortening behavior at faster speeds. This behavior is consistent with the function of these muscles serving mainly as struts to stabilize the limb for more economical weight support and to facilitate springlike behavior of the limb as a whole (6, 10, 14, 37). For both muscles, net shortening strain of the fascicles was <10% and much of this shortening occurred late in stance when muscle and ground forces are declining, suggesting that the amount of work performed by these muscles is relatively small. Interestingly, the MG shows less net shortening than the lateral gastrocnemius (14) over a range of speeds of locomotion, suggesting that the lateral gastrocnemius performs most of the muscle work at the ankle joint. However, the isometric or stretch-shortening behavior of the MG is consistent with significant elastic strain energy storage in the Achilles tendon shared by these two muscles, and this is borne out by the flexion-extension behavior of the ankle joint itself (Fig. 3).
Muscle recruitment and metabolic cost.
Because the ILPO and MG are actively recruited to support weight during stance, we predicted that the relative increase in EMG intensity of these muscles would be proportional to the relative increase in weight carried by the animal. This prediction assumes that the contractile pattern in these muscles is the same for both unloaded and loaded conditions; however, this was not the case. In the ILPO, the average increase in EMG intensity was 17% for a 22% load (Fig. 10), consistent with force enhancement due to increased active stretching of the muscle in early stance. By comparison, the average EMG intensity in the MG increased by 27%, in addition to undergoing greater active stretch during load carrying. This suggests a disproportionately greater increase in force production than required to support the additional load against gravity. One possible explanation for this is an increased need for braking and propulsive ground forces during loaded exercise. Adding a load to the body increases the mass that must be accelerated as well as supported against gravity, increasing the work that must be done. Recent modeling (19, 35) and experimental studies (11, 12, 29) of humans suggest that this cost is between 30 and 45% of the total cost of locomotion and the work is primarily done by ankle extensors (27, 43). It is also important to note that the relationship between EMG intensity and muscle force production is complex and likely nonlinear, given the recruitment of progressively larger fibers (faster motor units) at faster speeds and greater loads. Finally, there is little evidence to date that different limb muscles share equally in supporting additional loads that animals may carry. Consequently, differences in recruitment level and force output by different muscles may be expected to vary. Nevertheless, despite these caveats, our results based on our recordings of the ILPO and MG clearly indicate that the increased force requirement of load carrying is met mainly by increased muscle recruitment, which together matched the
22% body wt load that the animals carried.
|
18%) is also nearly identical to the increase in EMG intensity (22). Given its large size (26) and disproportionately high blood flow during exercise (21, 22, 39), the activity of this muscle likely has a large influence on the overall metabolic cost of locomotion in guinea fowl. However, the fractional increase in blood flow to the MG during trunk loaded running (22) is far less (
6%) than the increase in EMG intensity that we observe here (27%). Several factors, such as the degree of active stretching and subsequent shortening, differences in fiber type, and possible regional differences in recruitment levels within the two muscles at different levels of exercise intensity, are likely to influence EMG intensity and blood flow in different ways. To date, the relationships among EMG activity, blood flow and whole animal metabolic cost have yet to be explored in detail. Consequently, our differing results for these two muscles indicates that EMG intensity alone is not a reliable predictor of metabolic cost.
Recent studies of metabolic cost distribution between stance and swing phases suggest that swing phase accounts for
25% of the total cost of locomotion (18, 28, 38, 39, 41). Therefore, given an average increase in EMG intensity of stance phase muscles that is directly proportional to the increase in load (22% for each) we predicted that metabolic cost would increase by 75% of the increase in load, or by 16.5%. Our observation of a 17% increase in metabolic cost is consistent with this prediction. Thus, even though overall patterns of kinematics and energetics suggest little or no change in the contractile patterns of the muscles during loading, our results show that this is clearly not the case for the guinea fowl ILPO and MG. It is also evident that muscles in the leg do not all respond to loading in a uniform manner and likely serve multiple functions in addition to weight support. Additional work is needed to test the generality of our results for other limb muscles and other animals. Nevertheless, the results for the two hindlimb muscles studied here show that care must be taken when making simplifying assumptions regarding muscle function in relation to load-carrying exercise.
| GRANTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
O2 measuring systems. J Appl Physiol 51: 772776, 1981.This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
T. J. Roberts and A. M. Gabaldon Interpreting muscle function from EMG: lessons learned from direct measurements of muscle force Integr. Comp. Biol., August 1, 2008; 48(2): 312 - 320. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. M. Gabaldon, F. E. Nelson, and T. J. Roberts Relative shortening velocity in locomotor muscles: turkey ankle extensors operate at low V/Vmax Am J Physiol Regulatory Integrative Comp Physiol, January 1, 2008; 294(1): R200 - R210. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Scales and M. Butler Are powerful females powerful enough? Acceleration in gravid green iguanas (Iguana iguana) Integr. Comp. Biol., August 1, 2007; 47(2): 285 - 294. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. J. Roberts, B. K. Higginson, F. E. Nelson, and A. M. Gabaldon Muscle strain is modulated more with running slope than speed in wild turkey knee and hip extensors J. Exp. Biol., July 15, 2007; 210(14): 2510 - 2517. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. M. Griffin Powering locomotion? It's a loaded question J Appl Physiol, November 1, 2006; 101(5): 1273 - 1274. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||